6. If there are passages in Athanasius which seem
to favour the opposite interpretation, that is, to imply that the
Catholics held or allowed, as Bp. Bull considers, that ‘before
His generation, He was,’ they admit of an explanation. E.g.
“How is He not in the number of the creatures, if, as they say,
He was not before His generation? for it is proper to the creatures and
works, not to be before their generation.’ Orat. ii.
§22. This might be taken to imply that the Arians said, ‘He
was not,’ and Catholics ‘He was.’ But the real
meaning is this, ‘How is He not a creature, if the formula be
true, which they use, “He was not before His
generation?” for it may indeed properly be said of
creatures that “they were not before their
generation.”’ And so again when he says, ‘if the Son
was not before His generation, Truth was not always in God,’
supr. §20, he does not thereby imply that the Son was
before His generation, but he means, ‘if it be true that,
&c.,’ ‘if the formula holds,’ ‘if it
can be said of the Son, “He was not, &c.”’
Accordingly, shortly afterwards, in a passage already cited, he says
the same of the Almighty Father in the way of parallel; ‘God who
is, hath He so become, whereas He was not, or “is He too before
His generation?”’ (§25), not implying here any
generation at all, but urging that
the question is idle and irrelevant, that the formula is
unmeaning and does not apply to, cannot be said
of, Father or Son.