404 ON THE TRINITY. [bOOK XV.
say to him, Perhaps you are deceived ? when beyond doubt,
whereinsoever he may be deceived, he is nevertheless not
deceived in thinking that he wills not to be deceived. And
if he says he knows this, he adds any number he chooses of
things known, and perceives that number to be infinite. For
he who says, I will not to be deceived, and I know that I will
not to be so, and I know that I know it, is able now to set forth
an infinite number here also, however awkward may be the
expression of it. And other things too are to be found capable
of refuting the Academics, who contend that man can know
nothing. But we must restrict ourselves, especially as this
is not the subject we have undertaken in the present work.
There are three books of ours on that subject,^ written in the
early time of our conversion, which he who can and will read,
andwho understands them, will doubtless notbemuchmovedby
any of the many arguments which they have found out against
the discovery of truth. For whereas there are two kinds of
knowable things,—one, of those things which the mind per-
ceives by the bodily senses ; the other, of those which it per-
ceives by itself,—these philosophers have babbledmuch against
the bodily senses, but have never been able to throw doubt
upon those most certain perceptions of things true, which the
mind knows by itself, such as is that which I have mentioned,
I know that I am alive. But far be it from us to doubt the
truth of what we have learned by the bodily senses ; since by
them we have learned to know the heaven and the earth, and
those things in them which are known to us, so far as He who
created both us and them has willed them to be within our
knowledge. Far be it from us too to deny, that we know what
we have learned by the testimony of others : otherwise we know
not that there is an ocean ; we know not that the lands and
cities exist which most copious report commends to us ; we
laiow not that thosemen were, and their works, which we have
learned by reading history ; we know not the news that is daily
brought us from this quarter or that, and confirmed by consis-
tent and conspiring evidence ; lastly, we know not at what place
or from whom we have been born : since in all these things
we have believed the testimony of others. And if it is most
^ Libri Tres contra Academicos.