(3.) And whosoever, saying that Christ is God,
before ages Son of God, does not confess that He has subserved the
Father for the framing of the universe, be he anathema The
language of Catholics and heretics is very much the same on this point
of the Son’s ministration, with this essential difference of
sense, that Catholic writers mean a ministration internal to the divine
substance and an instrument connatural with the Father, and Arius meant
an external and created medium of operation. Thus S. Clement calls our
Lord ‘the All-harmonious Instrument (ὄργανον) of
God.’ Protrept. p. 6; Eusebius ‘an animated and
living instrument (ὄργανον
ἔμψυχον),
nay, rather divine and vivific of every substance and nature.’
Demonstr. iv. 4. S. Basil, on the other hand, insists that the
Arians reduced our Lord to ‘an inanimate
instrument,’ ὀργανον
ἄψυχον, though
they called Him ὑπουργὸν
τελειότατον, most perfect minister or underworker. adv. Eunom.
ii. 21. Elsewhere he makes them say, ‘the nature of a cause is
one, and the nature of an instrument, ὀργάνου,
another;….foreign then in nature is the Son from the Father,
since such is an instrument from a workman.’ De Sp. S. n.
6 fin. vid. also n. 4 fin. 19, and 20. And so S. Gregory, ‘The
Father signifies, the Word accomplishes, not servilely, nor ignorantly,
but with knowledge and sovereignty, and to speak more suitably, in a
father’s way, πατρικῶς. Orat. 30. 11. Cf. S. Cyril, in Joann. p. 48.
Explanations such as these secure for the Catholic writers some freedom
in their modes of speaking, e.g. Athan. speaks of the Son, as
‘enjoined and ministering,’ προσταττόμενος,
καὶ
ὑπουργῶν, Orat. ii. §22. Thus S. Irenæus speaks of the
Father being well-pleased and commanding, κελεύοντος, and the Son doing and framing. Hær. iv. 75.
S. Basil too, in the same treatise in which are some of the foregoing
protests, speaks of ‘the Lord ordering,’ προστάσσοντα, and the word framing.’ de Sp. S. n. 38, S.
Cyril of Jerusalem, of ‘Him who bids, ἐντελλεται, bidding to one who is present with Him,’ Cat.
xi. 16. vid. also ὑπηρετῶν
τῇ βουλῇ,
Justin. Tryph. 126, and ὑπουργόν, Theoph. ad Autol. ii. 10. ἑξυπηρετῶν
θελήματι, Clem. Strom. vii. p. 832..