Again, a certain Bishop Arsenius was said at one
time to have been made away with by Athanasius, but we have learned
that he is alive, nay, that he is on terms of friendship with him. He
has positively asserted that the Reports drawn up in the Mareotis were
ex parte ones; for that neither the Presbyter Macarius, the
accused party, was present, nor yet his Bishop, Athanasius himself.
This we have learnt, not only from his own mouth, but also from the
Reports which Martyrius, Hesychius and their fellows, brought to us Infr.
§83 fin.; for we found on reading them, that the
accuser Ischyras was present there, but neither Macarius, nor the
Bishop Athanasius; and that the Presbyters of Athanasius desired to
attend, but were not permitted. Now, beloved, if the trial was to be
conducted honestly, not only the accuser, but the accused also ought to
have been present. As the accused party Macarius attended at Tyre, as
well as the accuser Ischyras, when nothing was proved, so not only
ought the accuser to have gone to the Mareotis, but also the accused,
so that in person he might either be convicted, or by not being
convicted might shew the falseness of the accusation. But now, as this
was not the case, but the accuser only went out thither, with those to
whom Athanasius objected, the proceedings wear a suspicious
appearance.