3. Hefele, Conciliengeschicte. This,
the most recent work upon the subject, is also in some respects the
most satisfactory, and it is a matter of real regret that only the
first part of the work, down to the end of the Seventh Œcumenical
Council, has been translated into English. The last volume of the
author’s revised edition appeared in 1890. The first volume
of the first edition was published in 1855, and the seventh and last in
1874. The entire book was translated into French some years ago
(with full indices) by M. l’abbé Goschlerand and M.
l’abbé Delarc (Paris, Adrien le Clere et Cie). It
should in fairness, however, be remarked that Bishop Hefele was one of
the minority who opposed the opportuneness of the definition of Papal
infallibility at the Vatican Council, and while indeed afterwards he
submitted to the final decree, yet he has been a somewhat suspected
person since to those who held extreme views on this doctrine.