CHAP. I.
THE EVIDENCE OF ORIGINAL SIN, FROM THE NATURE OF REDEMPTION, IN THE PROCUREMENT OF IT.
According to Dr. T.‘s scheme, a very great part of mankind are the subjects of Christ’s
redemption,
who live and die perfectly
innocent,
who never have had, and never will have, any
sin
charged to their account, and never are exposed to any
punishment
whatsoever,
viz.
all that die in
infancy.
They are the subjects of
Christ’s redemption,
as he redeems them from
death,
or as they by his righteousness have
justification,
and by his obedience are
made righteous,
in the
resurrection
of the body, in the sense of
Rom. v. 18, 19.
And
all
mankind are thus the subjects of Christ’s redemption, while they are perfectly guiltless, and exposed to no punishment, as by Christ they are entitled to a
resurrection.
Though, with respect to such persons as have
sinned,
he allows it is
in some sort
by Christ and his death, that they are saved
from sin, and the punishment of it.
Now let us see whether such a scheme well consists with the scripture-account of the redemption by Jesus Christ.
I. The representations of the redemption by Christ, every where in Scripture, lead us to suppose, that
all
whom he came to redeem are
sinners
; that his salvation, as to the term
from which,
(or the evil to be redeemed from,) in
all,
is
sin,
and the deserved
punishment
of sin. It is natural to suppose, that when he had his name
Jesus,
or
Saviour,
given him by God’s special and immediate appointment, the
salvation meant by that name should be his salvation in general; and not only a
part
of his salvation, and with regard only to
some
of them whom he came to save. But this name was given him to signify
Matt. i. 21.
“his saving his people from their
sins
,” And the great doctrine of Christ’s salvation is, that
1 Tim. i. 15.
“he came into the world to save
sinners
,” And that
1 Pet. iii. 18.
“Christ hath
once suffered, the just for the
unjust
,”
1 John iv. 9, 10.
“In this was manifested the love of God towards us, (towards such in general as have the benefit of God’s love in giving Christ,) that God sent his only-begotten Son into the world, that we might live through him. Herein is love, that he sent his Son to be the propitiation for our
sins.
“ Many other texts might be mentioned, which seem evidently to suppose, that all who are redeemed by Christ are saved
from SIN. We are led by what Christ himself said, to suppose, that if any are not
sinners,
they have
no need
of him as a Redeemer, any more than a man in health of a physician,
Mark ii. 17.
And that, in order to our being the proper subjects of the mercy of God through Christ, we must first be in a state of
sin,
is implied in
Gal. iii. 22.
“But the Scripture hath concluded all under
sin,
that the promise by faith of Jesus
Christ might be given to them that believe.” To the same effect is
Rom. xi. 32.
These things are greatly confirmed by the scripture doctrine of
sacrifices.
It is abundantly plain, both from the Old and New Testament, that these were types of Christ’s death, and were for
sin,
and supposed
sin
in those for whom they were offered. The apostle supposes, that in order to any having the benefit of
the eternal inheritance
by Christ,
there must of necessity be the death of the testator
; and gives that reason for
it,
Heb. ix. 15
“That without shedding of blood there is no remission,” &c. And Christ himself, in representing the benefit of his blood, in the institution of the Lord’s supper, under the notion of the blood of a
testament,
calls it,
Matt. xxvi. 28
.“The blood of the New Testament shed for the
remission of sins
,” But according to the scheme of our author, many have the eternal inheritance by the death of the testator, who never had
any need of remission.
II. The Scripture represents the redemption by Christ, as a redemption from
deserved
destruction; and that, not merely as it respects some particulars, but as the fruit of God’s love to mankind.
John iii. 16.
“God so loved the
world,
that he gave his only-begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him
should not perish,
but have everlasting life;” implying, that otherwise they must perish, or be destroyed. But what necessity of
this, if they did not
deserve
to be destroyed? Now, that the destruction here spoken of, is deserved destruction, is manifest, because it is there compared to the perishing of such of the children of
Israel
as died by the bite of the fiery
serpents,
which God in his wrath, for their
rebellion,
sent amongst them. And the same thing clearly appears by the last verse of the same chapter, “He that believeth on the Son, hath everlasting life; and he that believeth not the
Son, shall not see life, but the wrath of God abideth on him,” or, is left remaining on him: implying, that all in general
are found
under the
wrath
of God, and that they only of all mankind who are interested in Christ, have this wrath
removed,
and eternal life bestowed; the rest are
left
with the
wrath of God still remaining on them.
The same is clearly illustrated and confirmed by
John v. 24.
“He that believeth, hath everlasting life,
and shall not come into condemnation, but is passed from death to life.” In being passed from death to life is implied, that
before,
they were all in a state of death; and they are spoken of as being so by a sentence of
condemnation
; and if it be a
just
condemnation, it is a
deserved
condemnation.
III. It will follow on Dr. T.‘s scheme, that Christ’s redemption, with regard to a great part of them who are the subjects of it, is not only a redemption from
no sin,
but from
no calamity,
and so from
no evil
of any kind. For as to
death,
which
infants
are redeemed from, they never were subjected to it as a calamity, but purely as a
benefit.
It came by no threatening or curse denounced upon or through Adam; the covenant with
him being utterly
abolished,
as to all its force and power on mankind, (according to our author,) before the sentence of mortality. Therefore trouble and death could be appointed to innocent mankind no other way than on account of another covenant, the covenant
of grace
; and in this channel they come only as
favours,
not as evils. Therefore they could need no remedy, for they had no disease. Even death itself, which it is supposed Christ saves them from, is only a
medicine; and one of the greatest of benefits. It is ridiculous to talk of persons’ needing a medicine, or a physician, to save them from an excellent medicine; or of a remedy from a happy remedy! If it be said, though death be a benefit, yet it is so because Christ
changes
it, and turns it into a benefit, by procuring a
resurrection
: I would ask, what can be meant by
turning
or
changing
it into a benefit, when it never
was
otherwise, nor could ever
justly be
otherwise?
Infants
could not at all be brought under death as a calamity; for they never
deserved
it. And it would be only an abuse (be it far from us, to ascribe such a thing to God) in any being, to offer any poor sufferers a Redeemer from a calamity which
he
had brought upon them, without the least
desert
of it on their part.
But it is plain, that mortality was not at first brought on mankind as a blessing, by the covenant of grace through Christ; and that Christ and grace do not
bring
mankind under death, but
find
them under it.
2 Cor. v. 14.
“We thus judge, that if one died for all, then were
all dead.
“
Luke xix. 10.
“The Son of man is come to seek and save that which was
lost.
“ The grace which appears in
providing a deliverer
from
any state, supposes the subject to be in that state
prior
to his deliverance. In our author’s scheme, there never could be any sentence of death or condemnation,
that requires a Savior from it; because the very sentence itself, according to the true meaning of it, implies and makes sure all that good, which is requisite to abolish and make void the seeming evil to the innocent subject. So that the sentence itself is in effect the deliverer;
and there is no need of another to deliver from that sentence. Dr. T. insists upon it, that “nothing comes upon us in consequence of
Adam’s
sin, in any sense, kind, or degree, inconsistent with the
original blessing
pronounced on Adam at his creation; and nothing but what is perfectly consistent with God’s blessing, love, and goodness, declared to Adam as soon as he came out of his Maker’s hands.”
338
If the case be so, it is certain there is no evil or calamity at all for Christ to redeem us from;
unless things agreeable to the divine goodness, love, and blessing,
are things from which we need redemption.
339
IV. It will follow, on our author’s principles, not only with respect to infants, but even
adult
persons, that redemption is
needless,
and Christ is dead in vain. Not only is there no need of Christ’s redemption in order to deliverance from any consequences of
Adam’s
sin, but also in order to perfect freedom from
personal
sin, and all its evil consequences. For God has made other sufficient provision for that,
viz. a sufficient power and
ability, in all mankind, to do all their duty, and wholly to avoid sin.
Yea, he insists upon it, that “when men have not sufficient
power
to do their duty, they have
no
duty to do. We may safely and assuredly conclude, (says he,) that mankind in all parts of the world have sufficient power to do the duty which God requires of them; and that he requires of them no more than they have sufficient powers to do.”
340
And in another place,
341
“God has given powers equal to the duty which he expects.” And he expresses a great dislike at R. R.‘s supposing, that our propensities to evil, and temptations, are too strong to be effectually and constantly resisted; or that we are unavoidably sinful in a degree; that our appetites and passions will be breaking out, notwithstanding our everlasting watchfulness.”
342
These things fully imply, that men have in their own natural ability sufficient means to avoid sin, and to be perfectly free from it; and so, from all the bad consequences of it. And if the means are
sufficient,
then there is no need
of more
; and therefore there is no need of Christ dying, in order to it. What Dr. T. says, (p. 72. S.) fully implies, that it would be unjust in God to give mankind being in such circumstances, as that they would be more likely to
sin, so as to be exposed to final misery, than otherwise. Hence then, without Christ and his redemption, and without any grace at all, mere justice makes
sufficient provision
for our being free from sin and misery, by our own power.
343
If all mankind, in all parts of the world, have such sufficient power to do their whole duty, without being sinful
in
any degree,
then they have sufficient power to obtain righteousness by the law: and then, according to the apostle Paul,
Christ is dead in vain
.
Gal. ii. 21.
“If righteousness come by law, Christ is dead in vain;”—
NOT ENGLISH
,
without the article,
by law,
or the rule of right action, as our
author explains the phrase.
344
And according to the sense in which he explains this very place, “it would have frustrated, or rendered useless, the grace of God, if Christ died to accomplish what was or might have been effected by law itself, without his death.”
345
So that it most clearly follows from his own doctrine,
that Christ is dead in vain,
and the grace of God is
useless.
The same apostle says,
if there had been a law
which could
have given life, verily righteousness should have been by the law
,
Gal. iii. 21.
i. e.
(still according to Dr. T.‘s own sense,) if there was a law, that man, in his present state, had sufficient power perfectly to fulfil. For Dr. T. supposes the reason
why the law could not give life, to be “not because it was weak in itself, but through the weakness of our flesh, and the infirmity of the human nature in the present state.”
346
But he says, “We are under a mild dispensation of GRACE, making allowance for our infirmities.”
347
By
our infirmities,
we may upon good grounds suppose he means that infirmity of human nature, which he gives as the reason why the law cannot give life. But what
grace
is there in making that allowance for our infirmities, which
justice
itself (according to his doctrine) most absolutely requires, as he supposes divine justice exactly proportions our duty to our ability?
Again, if it be said, that although Christ’s redemption was not necessary to preserve men from
beginning to sin,
and getting into a course of sin, because they have sufficient power in themselves to avoid it; yet it may be necessary to deliver men,
after
they have by their own folly brought themselves under the
dominion
of evil appetites and passions.
348
I answer, if it be so, that men need deliverance from those habits and passions, which are become too strong for them, yet that deliverance, on our author’s principles, would be no salvation from
sin.
For the exercise of passions which are too strong for us, and which we cannot overcome, is
necessary
: and he strongly urges, that a necessary evil can be no
moral
evil. It is true, it is the
effect
of evil, as it is the
effect
of a bad
practice, while the man had power to have avoided it. But then according to Dr. T. that evil
cause
alone is sin; for he says expressly, ”
The cause of
every effect is alone chargeable with the effect it produceth, or which proceedeth from it.”
349
And as to that sin which was the
cause,
the man needed no Saviour from
that,
having had
sufficient power
in himself to have avoided it. So that it follows by our author’s scheme, that
none
of mankind, neither infants nor adult persons, neither the more nor less vicious, neither
Jews
nor
Gentiles,
neither
heathens
nor
Christians,
ever did or ever could stand in any
need
of a Saviour; and that, with respect to
all,
the truth is,
Christ is dead in vain.
If any should say, although all mankind in all ages have sufficient ability to do their whole duty, and so may by their own power enjoy perfect freedom from sin, yet God
foresaw
that they
would sin,
and that
after
they had sinned, they would need Christ’s death. I answer, it is plain, by what the apostle says in those places which were just now mentioned, (
Gal. ii. 21.
and
Gal. iii. 21.
) that God would have
esteemed it needless to give his Son to die for men, unless there had been a prior impossibility of their having righteousness by any law; and that,
if there had been a law which
could
have given life,
this other way by the death of Christ would not have been provided. And this appears to be agreeable to our author’s own sense of things, by his words which have been cited, wherein he says, ” It would have frustrated or rendered useless the grace of God, if Christ died to
accomplish what was or might have been effected by law itself, without his death.”
V. It will follow on Dr. T.‘s scheme, not only that Christ’s redemption is
needless
for saving from sin, or its consequences, but also that it does
no good
that way, has no tendency to any
diminution
of
sin
in the world. For as to any
infusion
of virtue or holiness into the heart, by divine power through Christ or his redemption, it is altogether inconsistent with this author’s notions. With him,
inwrought
virtue, if there were
any such thing, would be
no
virtue; not being the effect of our own will, choice, and design, but only of a sovereign act of God’s power.
350
And therefore, all that Christ does to increase virtue, is only increasing our talents, our light, advantages, means, and motives; as he often explains the matter.
351
But
sin
is not at all diminished, for he says,
our duty must be measured by our talents
; as, a child that has less talents, has less duty; and therefore must be no more exposed to commit sin, than he that has greater talents; because he that has greater talents, has more duty required, in exact proportion.
352
If so, he that has but
one
talent, has as much
advantage
to perform that
one
degree of duty which is required of mm, as he that has
five
talents, to perform his
five
degrees of duty, and is no more exposed to fail of it. And that man’s
guilt,
who sins against
greater
advantages
means, and motives, is
greater
in proportion to his talents.
353
And therefore it will follow, on Dr. T.‘s principles, that men stand no better chance, have no more eligible or valuable probability of freedom from sin and punishment, or of contracting but little guilt, or of performing required duty, with the great advantages and talents implied in Christ’s redemption, than without them; when all things are computed, and put into the balances together, the numbers, degrees, and aggravations of sin exposed to, degrees of duty required, &c. So
that men have no redemption from sin, and no new means of performing duty, that are valuable or worth any thing at all. And thus the great redemption by Christ in every respect comes to nothing, with regard both to infants and adult persons.
338
Page 88. 89. S.
339
In this inferential short reply, our author it not quite so guarded as usual. It seems applicable only to infant; since adults have actual or personal sin and guilt from which to be redeemed. But what immediately follows anticipates the objection.—W.
340
Page 111. 68, 64. S.
341
Page 67. S.
342
Page 68. S.
343
Here, also, our author will be thought not quite accurate, in the inference lie draws against Dr. T. for the “sufficient power,” for which Dr. T. pleads, relates only to the prevention of sin, but not to its remission, or the removal of its effects. But this also will be soon answered.—W.
344
Pref. to Par. on Rom. p. 143. 38.
345
Note on
Rom. v. 20
. p. 297.
346
Ibid.
347
Page 92. S.
348
See p. 228. and also what he says of the helpless state of the heathen, in paraph. and notes on
Rom. vii.
and beginning of
chap. viii.
349
Page 128.
350
See p. 180, 245, 250
351
In p. 44, 50. and innumerable other places.
352
See page 234, 61, 64-72. S.
353
See Paraph, on
Rom. ii. 9.
also on ver. 12.