XII. An examination of the question where the ruling principle is to be considered to
reside; wherein also is a discussion of tears and laughter, and a physiological speculation as
to the inter-relation of matter, nature, and mind.1626
1. Let there be an end, then, of all the vain and conjectural discussion of those who
confine the intelligible energy to certain bodily organs; of whom some lay it down that the
ruling principle is in the heart, while others say that the mind resides in the brain,
strengthening such opinions by some plausible superficialities. For he who ascribes the
principal authority to the heart makes its local position evidence of his argument (because
it seems that it somehow occupies the middle position in the body1627), on the ground that
the motion of the will is easily distributed from the centre to the whole body, and so proceeds
to operation; and he makes the troublesome and passionate disposition of man a testimony
for his argument, because such affections seem to move this part sympathetically. Those,
on the other hand, who consecrate the brain to reasoning, say that the head has been built
by nature as a kind of citadel of the whole body, and that in it the mind dwells like a king,
with a bodyguard of senses surrounding it like messengers and shield-bearers. And these
find a sign of their opinion in the fact that the reasoning of those who have suffered some
injury to the membrane of the brain is abnormally distorted, and that those whose heads
are heavy with intoxication ignore what is seemly.
2. Each of those who uphold these views puts forward some reasons of a more physical
character on behalf of his opinion concerning the ruling principle. One declares that the
motion which proceeds from the understanding is in some way akin to the nature of fire,
because fire and the understanding are alike in perpetual motion; and since heat is allowed
to have its source in the region of the heart, he says on this ground that the motion of mind
is compounded with the mobility of heat, and asserts that the heart, in which heat is enclosed,
is the receptacle of the intelligent nature. The other declares that the cerebral membrane
(for so they call the tissue that surrounds the brain) is as it were a foundation or root of all
the senses, and hereby makes good his own argument, on the ground that the intellectual
energy cannot have its seat save in that part where the ear, connected with it, comes into
concussion with the sounds that fall upon it, and the sight (which naturally belongs to the
hollow of the place where the eyes are situated) makes its internal representation by means
of the images that fall upon the pupils, while the qualities of scents are discerned in it by
being drawn in through the nose, and the sense of taste is tried by the test of the cerebral
membrane, which sends down from itself, by the veterbræ of the neck, sensitive nerve-pro-
cesses to the isthmoidal passage, and unites them with the muscles there.
1626 In the Latin version chap. xii. includes only §§1—8 (incl.), to which the Bodleian ms. gives the title:—“That
the principle of man does not all reside in the brain, but in the whole body.”
1627 This view of the position of the heart is perhaps shared by Gregory himself: see e.g. ch. xxx. §15.
An examination of the question where the ruling principle is to be considered to reside; wherein also is a discussion of tears and laughter, and a physiological speculation as to the inter-relation of matter, nature, and mind.
735
An examination of the question where the ruling principle is to be considered…