2. A. No one doubts, Critobulus, that all things depend
on the judgment of Him Who is Creator of all, and that whatever we have
ought to be attributed to His goodness. But I should like to know
respecting this faculty, which you attribute to the grace of God,
whether you reckon it as part of the gift bestowed in our creation, or
suppose it energetic in our separate actions, so that we avail
ourselves of its assistance continually; or is it the case that, having
been once for all created and endowed with free will, we do what we
choose by our own choice or strength? For I know that very many of your
party refer all things to the grace of God in such a sense that they
understand the power of the will to be a gift not of a particular, but
of a general character, that is to say, one which is bestowed not at
each separate moment, but once for all at creation.