When I contemplate the condition
of the Church at the present crisis of affairs,—the tempest which
has recently beset the holy ship, the furious blasts, the beating of
the waves, the deep darkness of the night, and, besides all this, the
strife of the mariners, the struggle going on between oarsmen, the
drunkenness of the pilots, and, lastly, the untimely action of the
bad,—I bethink me of the laments of Jeremiah and cry with him,
“my bowels, my bowels! I am pained at my very heart, my heart
maketh a noise in me,” Jer. iv. 19 and to put away
despondency’s great cloud by the drops from my eyes, I have
recourse to founts of tears. Amid a storm so wild it is fitting that
the pilots be awake, to battle with the tempest, and take heed for the
safety of the ship: the sailors ought to cease from their strife, and
strive to undo the danger alike by prayer and skill: the mariners ought
to keep the peace, and quarrel neither with one another nor with the
pilots, but implore the Lord of the sea to banish the darkness by His
rod. No one now is willing to do anything of the kind; and, just as
happens in a night-engagement, we cannot recognise one another, we
leave our enemies alone, and waste our weapons against our own side; we
wound our comrades for foes, while all the while the bystanders laugh
at our drunken folly, enjoy our disasters, and are delighted to see us
engaged in mutual destruction. The responsibility for all this lies
with those who have striven to corrupt the apostolic faith, and have
dared to add a monstrous doctrine to the teaching of the Gospels; with
them that have accepted the impious “Chapters” which they
have sent forth with anathematisms to the imperial city, and have
confirmed them, as they have imagined, by their own signatures. But
these “Chapters” have sprouted without doubt from the sour
root of Apollinarius; they are tainted with Arian and Eunomian error;
look into them carefully, and you will find that they are not clear of
the impiety of Manes and Valentinus. “Nihil contumeliosius,” remarks Garnerius, “in Cyrilli personam et doctrinam dici
potest.” Some have even thought the expressions too bitter
for Theodoret. But the mild man could hit hard sometimes. He felt
warmly for Nestorius and against Cyril, and (accepting
Tillemont’s date) he was now about 38.