It will hardly be agreed that imperial succession is a law of
nature anyway. Rather, “the succession [where it exists] is
established by the express will or the tacit consent of the
nation,” and the “pretended proprietary right…is a
chimera” (Vattell, Law of Nations, Phila., 1867, p. 24,
25). That primogeniture is a natural law has been often urged, but it
seems to be simply the law of first come first served. The English
custom of primogeniture is said to have risen from the fact that in
feudal times the eldest son was the one who, at the time of the
father’s death, was of an age to meet the duties of feudal tenure
(compare Kent, Commentaries, Boston, 1867, v. 4, p. 420, 421).
This is precisely the fact respecting Constantine. His several brothers
were all too young to be thought of.