The
syllogism implied in the following words is this:—
The emotions are something
intellectual (because incorporeal).
Therefore the emotions are soul
(or souls).
This conclusion is
obviously false; logically, by reason of the fallacy of “the
undistributed middle”; ontologically, because it requires a false
premise additional (i.e. “everything intellectual is
soul”) to make it true. Macrina directly after this piece of bad
logic deprecates the use of the syllogism. Is this accidental? It looks
almost like an excuse for not going into technicalities and exposing
this fallacy, which she has detected in her opponent’s statement.
Macrina actually answers as if Gregory had urged his objection thus.
“The emotions are not purely intellectual, but are conditioned by
the bodily organism: but they do belong to the expression and the
substance of the soul: the soul therefore is dependent on the organism
and will perish along with it.”