And all the Bishops of Egypt and Libya wrote and
protested Supr.
§6. that his ordination was lawful and
strictly ecclesiastical, and that all that you had advanced against him
was false, for that no murder had been committed, nor any persons
despatched on his account, nor any cup broken, but that all was false.
Nay, the Bishop Athanasius also shewed from the ex parte reports
drawn up in the Mareotis, that a catechumen was examined and said Infr.
§83., that he was within with Ischyras, at the
time when they say Macarius the Presbyter of Athanasius burst into the
place; and that others who were examined said,—one, that Ischyras
was in a small cell,—and another, that he was lying down behind
the door, being sick at that very time, when they say Macarius came
thither. Now from these representations of his, we are naturally led to
ask the question, How was it possible that a man who was lying behind
the door sick could get up, conduct the service, and offer? and how
could it be that Oblations were offered when catechumens were within Bingh.
Ant. X. v. 8.? for if there were catechumens present, it
was not yet the time for presenting the Oblations. These
representations, as I said, were made by the Bishop Athanasius, and he
showed from the reports, what was also positively affirmed by those who
were with him, that Ischyras has never been a presbyter at all in the
Catholic Church, nor has ever appeared as a presbyter in the assemblies
of the Church; for not even when Alexander admitted those of the
Meletian schism, by the indulgence of the great Council, was he named
by Meletius among his presbyters, as they deposed Infr.
§71.;
which is the strongest argument possible that he was not even a
presbyter of Meletius; for otherwise, he would certainly have been
numbered with the rest. Besides, it was shewn also by Athanasius from
the reports, that Ischyras had spoken falsely in other instances: for
he set up a charge respecting the burning of certain books, when, as
they pretend, Macarius burst in upon them, but was convicted of
falsehood by the witnesses he himself brought to prove it.