44. How, then, does Power assert, as it were, under oath: “Verily, verily I say unto you,”
which means: “Of a truth, of a truth, I tell you”?1586 Truly, then, Thou speakest, Lord Jesus,
and dost affirm, repeating indeed thy solemn declaration, that Thou canst do nothing, save
what Thou hast seen the Father doing. Thou didst make the universe. Did Thy Father then
make another universe, for Thee to take as a model? So must Thy blasphemers confess that
there are two, or a multitude of universes, as philosophers affirm, and thus also entangle
themselves in this heathen error,1587 or, if they will follow the truth, let them say that what
Thou hast made, Thou didst make, without any pattern.
45. Tell me, Lord, when Thou sawest Thy Father incarnate, and walking upon the sea,
for I know not, I hold it impious to believe this thing of the Father, knowing that Thou only
hast taken our flesh upon Thee. When sawest Thou the Father at a marriage-feast, turning
water into wine?1588 Nay, but I have read that Thou alone art the only Son, begotten of the
Father. I have been taught that Thou alone, in the mystery of the Incarnation, wast born of
the Holy Ghost and the Virgin. The things, then, which we have cited as Thy doings, the
Father did not, but Thou alone, without guidance of any work done by Thy Father, for the
purchase of the world’s salvation with Thy Blood, didst come forth spotless from the Virgin’s
womb.
46. When they say, “The Son can do nothing of Himself,” they indeed except nothing,
268
so that one blasphemer has even said: “He cannot make even a gnat,”1589 mocking with so
headstrong profanity and with insolence so overweening the majesty of Supreme Power;
yet perhaps they may think the mystery of Thine Incarnate Life a needful exception. But
say, Lord Jesu, what earth the Father made without Thee. For without Thee He made no
heaven, seeing that it is written: “By the Word of the Lord were the heavens established.”
47. But neither did the Father make the earth without Thee, for it is written: “All things
were made by Him, and without Him was not anything made.”1590 For if the Father made
aught without Thee, God the Word, then not all things were made by the Word, and the
Evangelist lies. Whereas if all things were made by the Word, and if by Thee all things begin
to be, which before were not, then surely Thou Thyself, of Thyself, hast made what Thou
didst not see made by the Father; though perchance our adversaries may have recourse to
that theory of Plato, and place before Thee the ideas supposed by philosophers, which, indeed,
1586 S. John v. 19.
1587 Namely, the error of postulating two mutually exclusive infinites.
1588 S. John ii. 4. For the walking on the sea, vide S. Mark vi. 48.
1589 As a matter of fact, gnats and insects generally are far from being the least wonderful of God’s works.
In them as much as, if not more than, in anything we may recognize His eternal power and wisdom and Godhead.
Cf. Prov. vi. 6–8.
1590 S. John i. 3; Ps. xxxiii. 6.
597
Chapter IV. The passage quoted adversely by heretics, namely, “The Son can…