306 THE SEVEN BOOKS OF [Book vir.
sacrificing of fruitful and barren victims to mother earth and the virgin
Minerva, such reasoning requires that musicians should be sacrificed to
Apollo, physicians to ZÉsculapius, and orators to Mercury (22). Re-
turning to the argument, that sacrifices should be offered to the gods to
win favours from the good, to avert the malice of the bad, Arnobius
points out, first, that it is impossible that there should be evil deities ;
and, secondly, that to suppose that the sacrifices were effectual, is to
suppose that by them an evil deity could be changed into a good, and
that, through their being withheld, a beneficent deity might become
malevolent ; which is as absurd as if one were to expect, on caressing a
viper or scorpion, that he would escape being stung (23). He proceeds
to call attention to various kinds of puddings, cakes, pottages, and
other delicacies used in ceremonies, asking with scorn for what end
they were employed (24, 25). It is next pointed out, that no reason
can be offered for the use of incense, which was certainly unknown in
the heroic ages, and unused even in Etruria, the mother of superstition,
and could not have been burned on the altar until after the time of
Numa. If, therefore, the ancients were not guilty in neglecting to burn
incense, it could not be necessary to do so (26). Moreover, of what
service was incense to the gods? If they were honoured by its being
burned, why should not any gum be so used (27)? If incense is pre-
ferred because of its sweet smell, the gods must have noses, and share
man’s nature. Further, they may not be affected as we are by odours,
and what is pleasant to us may be disagreeable to them; and vice versa.
But such considerations are inadmissible with regard to the gods, for
reason demands that they should be immaterial, and that therefore they
should not be affected by odours (28). Arnobius next shows that the
use of wine in ceremonies was as little based on reason as that of
incense, for deities cannot be affected by thirst (29) ; and how could
they be honoured with that which excites to vice and impairs man’s
reason (20)? The formula with which libations were made is ridiculed
as niggardly and stingy (931) ; and the wreaths and garlands worn by
the celebrants, and the noise and clangour of their musical instruments,
are also turned into mockery (32) ; whilst it is shown that, to speak of
the gods being honoured by the games dedicated to them, is to say that
they were honoured by being publicly insulted in the ribald plays which
were acted at these times, and by licentious and lustful conduct (33).
All these detestable opinions originated in man's inability to under-
stand what the deity really is, and in his therefore attributing to the
divine nature what belongs to himself alone (34). In the three chap-
ters which follow, he contrasts the opinions of heathen and Christians
as to the divine nature, showing that to the former nothing seemed too
bad to be attributed to their gods ; while the latter, not professing to
worship the gods, insulted them less by not holding such opinions
(35-37).