7. And so too on examination there are grounds for saying that the Son is
“one in essence” with the Father; not in the way of bodies,
nor like mortal beings, for He is not such by division of essence, or
by severance, no, nor by any affection, or alteration, or changing of
the Father’s essence and power This
was the point on which the Semi-arians made their principal stand
against the “one in essence,” though they also objected to
it as being of a Sabellian character. E.g. Euseb. Demonstr. iv.
3. p. 148. d.p. 149. a, b. v. 1. pp. 213–215. contr.
Marcell. i. 4. p. 20. Eccl. Theol. i. 12. p. 73. in
laud. Const. p. 525. de Fide i. ap. Sirmond. tom. i.
p. 7. de Fide ii. p. 16, and apparently his de
Incorporali. And so the Semi-arians at Ancyra Epiph.
Hær. 73. 11. p. 858. a, b. And so Meletius ibid. p. 878
fin. and Cyril Hier. Catech. vii. 5. xi. 18. though of course
Catholics would speak as strongly on this point as their
opponents. (since from all
such the unoriginate nature of the Father is alien), but because
“one in essence with the Father” suggests that the Son of
God bears no resemblance to the originated creatures, but that to His
Father alone Who begat Him is He in every way assimilated, and that He
is not of any other subsistence and essence, but from the Father Here
again Eusebius does not say “from the Father’s
essence,” but “not from other essence, but from the
Father.” According to note 5, supr. he considered the will of God
a certain matter or substance. Montfaucon in loc. and Collect.
Nov. Præf. p. xxvi. translates without warrant “ex
Patris hypostasi et substantiâ.” As to the Son’s
perfect likeness to the Father which he seems here to grant, it has
been already shewn, de Decr. 20, note 9, how the admission was
evaded. The likeness was but a likeness after its own kind, as a
picture is of the original. “Though our Saviour Himself
teaches,” he says, “that the Father is the ‘only true
God,’ still let me not be backward to confess Him also the true
God, ‘as in an image,’ and that possessed; so that the
addition of ‘only’ may belong to the Father alone as
archetype of the image.…As, supposing one king held sway, and his
image was carried about into every quarter, no one in his right mind
would say that those who held sway were two, but one who was honoured
through his image; in like manner,” &c. de Eccles.
Theol. ii. 23, vid. ibid. 7.. To which term also, thus interpreted, it
appeared well to assent; since we were aware that even among the
ancients, some learned and illustrious Bishops and writers Athanasius in like manner, ad Afros. 6. speaks of
“testimony of ancient Bishops about 130 years since;” and
in de Syn. §43. of “long before” the Council of
Antioch, a.d. 269. viz. the Dionysii, &c.
vid. note on de Decr. 20. have used the term “one in
essence,” in their theological teaching concerning the Father and
Son.