There is properly
enough a recognition of God in history; the sovereign will and the
human will are jointly working out the world’s order, but it is
the attempt to trace the cause and effect immediately and in each case,
which is so repulsive and absurd. Some illustrations will show how he
brings out this view. In i. 7 the comment made on Constantine’s
overthrow of Licinius: “From many facts it has often appeared to
me that the teaching of the Christians is supported, and its
advancement secured, by the Providence of God, and not the least from
what then occurred; for at the very moment that Licinius was about to
persecute all the churches under him, the war in Bithynia broke out,
which ended in a war between him and Constantine, and in which
Constantine was so strengthened by Divine assistance, that he was
victorious over his enemies by land and by sea.” More of detail
comes out in the life of Athanasius. Thus in ii. 17, of his election he
says: “Alexander, bishop of Alexandria, when about to depart this
life, left Athanasius as his successor, in accordance, I am convinced,
with the Divine will, directing the vote upon him.” And again:
“He fled to escape the honor, but he was discovered in his place
of concealment by the help of God, who had forecast by Divine
manifestations to his blessed predecessors, that the succession was to
devolve upon him.” His whole career is so viewed in v. 6. There
is a large discussion of this subject in vi. 35, where he argues
against the plan of pagan philosophers to foretell the future of the
empire: “The philosophers, on the other hand, acted as if the
deposition and restoration of emperors had depended solely on them; for
if the imperial succession was to be considered dependent on the
arrangement of the stars, what was requisite but to await the accession
of the future emperor, whoever he might be? Or, if the succession was
regarded as dependent on the will of God, what right had man to meddle?
For it is not the function of human foreknowledge or zeal to understand
God’s thought; nor if it were right, would it be well for men,
even if they be the wisest of all, to think that they can plan better
than God.” He persists in tracing a connection between God and
every event in favor of mechanical goodness or orthodoxy. He follows
many opponents, whether heretical or pagan, with the Divine wrath; all
these historians do this,—Philostorgius, as well as Evagrius.
Sozomen is not nearly so bitter or uncharitable as either of these. He
is most atrabilious in the case of Julian, under whom his own family
had suffered. As a consequence of this arbitrary pious pragmatism, the
most deplorable incompetents are treated as the express favorites of
heaven, while the larger-minded pagan or Arian is loaded with contempt.
Under this law, too, the evil sides of the orthodox, and the
excellences of the pagan, or Arians, are suppressed. The defeats of the
Nicene emperors are not mentioned; the victories of the Anti-Nicene are
passed by or belittled, while their humiliations are evidence of the
impending anger of heaven. In the survey of Helena’s life (ii. 2)
he says: “It seems to me that so many holy actions demanded a
recompense, and indeed even in this life she was raised to the summit
of magnificence.” As to Constantine, in ii. 34 he dares say:
“He was more successful than any other sovereign in all his
undertakings; for he formed no design, I am convinced, without
God.” When Bishop Felix of Rome died, and Liberius became sole
occupant of the see, he construes the fact thus: “This event was
no doubt ordained by God, that the seat of Peter might not be
dishonored by the occupancy of two bishops; for such an arrangement is
a sign of discord, and is foreign to ecclesiastical law” (iv.
15). In all the features of Julian’s life, God is visiting him
with his unappeasable anger (vi. 35, v. 21, 22, vi. 1, 2). The election
of Nectarius, though it was in violation of ecclesiastical order and an
accumulation of ignorant blunders, did not take place without the
interposition of Divine strength (vii. 8). Theodosius is portrayed as
the prime delight of heaven; thus his simple reliance upon God wins him
a hopeless battle with Eugenius (vii. 24). It is so with the whole
Theodosian line (viii. 1, ix. 1). Pulcheria has Divine love manifested
to her in manifold ways, as does her brother, Theodosius the Younger
(ix. 1, 3, 16). Even Alaric is driven by an inexplicable impulse to
rebuke the luxury, debauchery, and injustice of the Romans (ix. 6). In
ix. 1, he says of his own sovereign: “It appears to me that it
was the design of God to show by the events of this period, that piety
alone suffices for the salvation of princes; and that without piety, armies, a
powerful empire, and every other resource, are of no avail. The Divine
power, which is the guardian of the universe, foresaw that the emperor
would be distinguished by his piety, and determined that Pulcheria, his
sister, should be the protector of him and of the government.” In
ix. 16, he explains his secular details in the paragraph: “This
is not the proper place to enter into details concerning the deaths of
the tyrants; but I considered it necessary to allude to the
circumstance in order to show, that to insure the stability of imperial
power, it is sufficient for an emperor to serve God with reverence,
which was the course pursued by Honorius.” While of his patron he
says: “It seems as if God openly manifested His favor towards the
present emperor, not only by disposing of warlike affairs in an
unexpected way, but also by revealing the sacred bodies of many persons
who were of old most distinguished for piety.” The whole history
is full of this sort of philosophy of its personages. Similarly all
natural calamities and the irruption of barbarians are ethically
explained, which is correct enough as a general principle; but these
phenomena are punitive or vindicatory of particular deeds.
Constantius’ course toward Athanasius was heralded by an invasion
of the Franks, and by an earthquake in the East (iii. 6). Of Julian he
says: “It is, however, very obvious that throughout the reign of
this emperor, God gave manifest tokens of His displeasure and permitted
many calamities to befall several of the provinces of the Roman Empire.
He visited the earth with such fearful earthquakes, that the buildings
were shaken, and no more safety could be found within houses than in
the open air.” Then follow the inundations of the Nile; the
drought and the famine in the empire, and on their heels the
pestilences (vi. 2). Under Valens we read: “In the meantime
although hail-storms of extraordinary magnitude fell in various places,
and although many cities, particularly Nicæa in Bithynia, were
shaken by earthquakes, yet Valens the emperor and Eudoxius the bishop
paused not in their career, but continued to persecute all Christians
who differed from them in opinion” (vi. 10). He does not make the
same reflection upon Constantius, when the earthquake at Nicomedia
intercepted the meeting of a council (iv. 16); Gaïnas’
attempted revolution is “pre-announced by the appearance of a
comet directly over the city; this comet was of extraordinary
magnitude, larger, it is said, than any that had previously been
seen” (viii. 3). After Chrysostom’s exile,
“hailstones of extraordinary magnitude fell at Constantinople and
in the suburbs of the city. Four days afterwards, the wife of the
emperor died. These occurrences were regarded by many as indications of
Divine wrath, on account of the persecutions that had been carried on
against John” (viii. 27).