529
AN APPENDIX.
Being a Letter to the people of the first church and congregation in Northampton.
Dear brethren,
Though I am not now your pastor, yet having so long stood in that relation to you, I
look on myself obliged, notwithstanding all that has of late passed between us, still to
maintain a special concern for your spiritual welfare. And as your present circumstances
appear to me very evidently attended with some peculiar dangers, threatening the great
wounding of the interest of vital religion among you; which probably most of you are not
well aware of; I look on myself called to point forth your danger to you, and give you
warning. What I now especially have respect to, is the danger I apprehend you are in, from
the contents of that book of Mr. W. of Lebanon, to which the foregoing performance is a
reply; which I perceive has been written and published very much by your procurement
and at your expense; and so (it may naturally be supposed and expected) is dispersed in
your families, and will be valued and much used by you as a book of great importance. What
I regard, is not so much the danger you are in of being established by that book in your
former principles, concerning the admission of members; (though I think these principles
are indeed very opposite to the interest of true piety in churches;) but what I now mean is
the danger there is, that while you are making much of that book as a means to maintain
Mr. Stoddard’s doctrine concerning the terms of communion, you, and especially your
children, will by the contents of it be led quite off from other religious principles and doc-
trines, which Mr. S. brought you up in, and always esteemed as of vastly greater importance,
than his particular tenet about the Lord’s supper; and be naturally led into notions and
principles, which he ever esteemed as of fatal tendency to the souls of men.
By the way, I would have it observed, that when I take notice of these things in his book,
my aim is not to beget in you an ill opinion of Mr. W. as though he were as corrupt in his
settled persuasion, as one would be ready to think, if he were to judge only by things delivered
in some parts of this book; and especially if it should be supposed, that he embraced all the
consequences of what he here maintains. Men often do not see or allow the plain consequences
of their own doctrines. And therefore, though I charge very pernicious consequences on
some things he says, yet I do not charge him with embracing these consequences: nor will
I undertake to explain how it could come to pass, that he should maintain things now in
this book, in opposition to me, which are so contrary to the good and sound doctrines he
has formerly delivered in other books. Let that be as it will, and however orthodox the
530
principles may be, which he more ordinarily maintains; yet the ill and unsound things he
delivers here, may do nevertheless hurt to you and your children, who may read this book
without having in view the more wholesome doctrines of his other writings.
For instance, you have ever been taught, that unconverted men do not really believe the
gospel, are never truly convinced of its truth.; and that it is of great importance that sinners
Appendix. A letter to the people of Northampton.
2031
Appendix. A letter to the people of Northampton.