that he was ‘the son of Heli, which was the son of Matthat,’ and so by ascending brings his
enumeration up to Adam; but when he has come to the top and said, that Seth ‘was the son
of Adam, which was the son of God,’ then he stops this process. As, then, he has said that
Adam was the son of God, we will ask these men, ‘But God, who is He the son of?’ Is it not
obvious to every one’s intelligence that God is the son of no one? But to be the son of no
one is to be without a cause, plainly; and to be without a cause is to be ungenerate. Now in
the case of men, the being son of somebody is not the essence1215; no more, in the case of
the Deity Who rules the world, is it possible to say that the being ungenerate is the essence.”
313
With what eyes will you now dare to gaze upon your guide? I speak to you, O flock1216
of perishing souls! How can you still turn to listen to this man who has reared such a
monument as this of his shamelessness in argument? Are ye not ashamed now, at least, if
not before, to take the hand of a man like this to lead you to the truth? Do ye not regard it
as a sign of his madness as to doctrine, that he thus shamelessly stands out against the truth
contained in Scripture? Is this the way to play the champion of the truth of doctrine—namely,
to accuse Basil of deriving the God over all from that which has absolutely no existence?
Am I to tell the way he phrases it? Am I to transcribe the very words of his shamelessness?
I let the insolence of them pass; I do not blame their invective, for I do not censure one
whose breath is of bad odour, because it is of bad odour; or one who has bodily mutilation,
1215 οὐκ ἦν οὐσία τὸ ἔκ τινος. This is Oehler’s reading from the mss.
1216 O flock. This could not have been written earlier than 384, and there is abundant testimony that Euno-
mius still had his “flock.” Long before this, even soon after he had left his see of Cyzicus, and had taken up his
abode with Eudoxius, he separated himself from that champion of the Homœan party, and held assemblies
apart because he had repeatedly entreated that his preceptor Aetius might be received into communion (Socrates
iv. 13). This must have been about 366, before his banishment by Valens for favouring the rebellion of Procopius.
Sozomen says (vi. 29), “The heresy of Eunomius was spread from Cilicia and the Mountains of Taurus as far as
the Hellespont and Constantinople.” In 380 at Bithynia near Constantinople “multitudes resorted to him, some
also gathered from other quarters, a few with the design of testing his principles, and others merely from the
desire of listening to his discourses. His reputation reached the ears of the Emperor, who would gladly have had
a conference with him. But the Empress Flacilla studiously prevented an interview taking place between them;
for she was the most faithful guard of the Nicene doctrines” (vii. 17). At the convention, however, of all the sects
at Theodosius’ palace in 382, Eunomius was present (Socrates v. 10). His ἔκθεσις τῆς πίστεως (to which he added
learned notes) was laid before Theodosius in 383. It was not till 391 that the Emperor condemned him to ban-
ishment—the sole exception to Theodosius’ toleration. “This heretic,” says Sozomen again, “had fixed his residence
in the suburbs of Constantinople and held frequent assemblies in private houses, where he read his own writings.
He induced many to embrace his sentiments, so that the sectarians who were named after him became very
numerous. He died not long after his banishment, and was interred at Dacora, his birthplace, a village of Cap-
padocia.”
584
Answer to Eunomius' Second Book.