To justify has always, in common speech, signified indifferently, either simply approb-
ation, or testifying that approbation; sometimes one, and sometimes the other; because they
are both the same, only as one is outwardly what the other is inwardly. So we, and it may
be all nations, are wont to give the same name to two things, when one is only declarative
of the other. Thus sometimes judging, intends only judging in our thoughts; at other times,
651
testifying and declaring judgment. So such words as justify, condemn, accept, reject, prize,
slight, approve, renounce, are sometimes put for mental acts, at other times, for an outward
treatment. So in the sense in which the apostle James seems to use the word justify for
manifestative justification, a man is justified not only by faith, but also by works; as a tree is
manifested to be good, not only by immediately examining the tree, but also by the fruit,
481 Prov. xx. 11. “Even a child is known by his doing, whether his work be pure, and
whether it be right.”
481 This distinction is just and scriptural as far as it goes, but it does not reach the bottom of the difficulty,
since believing in order to justification is itself a part of obedience, and is expressly called “the obedience of
faith.” Hence justification by faith, in comparison of what precedes it, is only manifestative. The tree must be
good, that is, the person must be vitally united to Christ, as the adequate cause of believing, otherwise he would
be still carnal. The faith of a man spiritually dead or carnal, must needs be a dead faith; but to suppose that such
faith unites to Christ, has neither Scripture nor any plausible reason to support it. To him that is in Christ Jesus
by a vital union, there is no condemnation; and as there is no medium between condemnation and justification,
he who is in Christ is justified, or “accepted in the beloved” Saviour. That union which Christ effects by his
quickening Spirit, makes the tree good, and believing with the heart, in order to receive the promised righteous-
ness, is the fruit of a good tree. Therefore the justification which is received as the consequence of believing is
only manifestative of union; even as justification by works, as asserted by St. James, is manifestative of a living
faith. As without works there is no sufficient evidence of union to Christ on our part, so without faith in Christ
as our complete righteousness, there is no sufficient evidence of union with him on his part. The true Christian’s
works, are “works of faith and labours of love,” performed in obedience to God’s authority, directed to his glory,
and inspired by gratitude for the blessings of his grace, and this is the first of all such works, called “the work of
God,” even to believe on Jesus Christ in whom alone is righteousness and life. By believing we receive the divine
testimony respecting a gratuitous righteousness, and renounce all hope of obtaining justification by any other
way. The justifying righteousness is only one, but the appointed ways of becoming interested in it are divers.
One way is by the will of God our Saviour, the other by the will of man the accountable agent, each in its own
order. The will of God gives the fundamental interest, and the will of man the consequent and manifestative
interest. In the first way, we are interested in Christ’s righteousness by one act continued, commencing with,
and permanent as, the primary vital union; in the other way, it is by repeated acts, commencing with the first
act of faith in Christ, and repeated with every succeeding reception of him. Among persons who have made any,
even the smallest, progress in christian knowledge, there can be no dispute respecting the fundamental cause
of justification. All such acknowledge, that the righteousness, or federal perfection of Jesus Christ, is that for
the sake of which any of the fallen race of Adam can be justified. The difference of sentiment arises from the
2366
DISCOURSE. I. Justification by Faith alone.