AGAINST THE PELAGIANS.— BOOK I. 453
through a needle's eye, than for a rich man
to enter into the kingdom of heaven." And yet he said a thing might possibly happen,
which never has happened. For no camel
has ever gone through a needle's eye. A. I am surprised at a prudent man sub-
mitting evidence which goes against himself.
For the passage in question does not speak
of a possibility, but one impossibility is com-
pared with another. As a camel cannot go
through a needle's eye, so neither will a rich man enter the kingdom of heaven. Or, if you
should be able to show that a rich man does
enter the kingdom of heaven, it follows, also,
that a camel goes through a needle's eye. You must not instance Abraham and other
rich men, about whom we read in the Old
Testament, who, although they were rich,
entered the kingdom of heaven ; for, by spend-
ing their riches on good works, they ceased to
be rich ; nay, rather, inasmuch as they were
rich, not for themselves, but for others, they
ought to be called God's stewards rather than rich men. But we must seek evangelical per-
fection, according to which there is the com-
mand,1 " If thou wilt be perfect, go and sell all that thou hast, and give to the poor, and
come, follow Me." ir. C. You are caught unawares in your own snare.
A. How so ?
C. You quote our Lord's utterance to the effect that a man can be perfect. For when
He says, "If thou wilt be perfect, sell all that thou hast, and give to the poor, and come,
follow Me," He shows that a man, if he chooses, and if he does what is commanded,
can be perfect ?
A. You have given me such a terrible blow
that I am almost dazed. But yet the very
words you quote, " If thou wilt be perfect," vere spoken to one who could not, or rather
ould not, and, therefore, could not ; show
me now, as you promised, some one who ould and could.
C. Why am I compelled to produce in-
tances of perfection, when it is clear from
vhat the Saviour said to one, and through
ne to all, "It ihou wilt be perfect," that it is ossible for men to be perfect ? A. That is a mere shuffle. You still stick
ast in the mire. For, either, if a thing is
'ossible, it has occurred at some time or
ther ; or, if it never has happened, grant
hat it is impossible.
12. C. Why do I any longer delay? You
nust be vanquished by the authority of Scrip-
ure. To pass over other passages, you
nust be silenced by the two in which we read
1 S. Matt. xix. ai.
the praises of Job, and of Zacharias and
Elizabeth. For, unless I am deceived, it is thus
written in the book of Job : ' " There was a man in the land of Uz, whose name was Job ;
and that man was perfect and upright, a true
worshipper of God, and one who kept him-
self from every evil thing." And again :
" Who is he that reproveth one that is right- eous and free from sin, and speaketh words
without knowledge ? " Also, in the Gospel
according to Luke, we read : 3 " There was in the days of Herod, king of Judaea, a
certain priest named Zacharias, of the course
of Abijah : and he had a wife of the daugh-
ters of Aaron, and her name was Eliza-
beth. And they were both righteous before
God, walking in all the commandments
and ordinances of the Lord blameless." If a true worshipper of God is also without
spot and without offence, and if those who walked in all the ordinances of the Lord are
righteous before God, I suppose they are free
from sin, and lack nothing that pertains to
righteousness.
A. You have cited passages which have
been detached not only from the rest of Scrip-
'ture, but from the books in which they oc- cur. For even Job, after he was stricken with
the plague, is convicted of having spoken
many things against the ruling of God, and
to have summoned Him to the bar. : 4 " Would that a man stood with God in the judgment
as a son of man stands with his fellow."
And again : 6 " Oh that I had one to hear me ! that the Almighty might hear my de-
sire, and that the judge would himself write
a book ! " And again : * " Though I be righteous, mine own mouth shall condemn
me : though I be perfect, it shall prove me
perverse. If I wash myself with snow-water, and make my hands never so clean, Thou hast
dyed me again and again with filth. Mine
own clothes have abhorred me." And of Zacharias it is written, that when the angel
promised the birth of a son, he said :
7 " Whereby shall I know this ? for I am an
old man, and my wife well stricken in years." For which answer he was at once condemned
to silence : 8 " Thou shall be silent, and not able to speak, until the day that these
things shall come to pass, because thou be- lievest not my words, which shall be fulfilled
in their season." From this it is clear that
men are called righteous, and said to be with-
out fault ; but that, if negligence comes over
> Job i. i.
* This appears to be an inaccurate quotation made from memory.
J S. Luke i. 5 sqq.
* Job xvi. 21. Vulg. R. V. Margin — " That one might plead for
a man with God as a son of man pleadeth for his neighbour."
* Job xxxi. 35. ' Job ix.
* S. Luke i. 18. ' Ib. ao.
20, 30, 31.