“If any does not
admit Mary to be the Mother of God (θεοτόκον), he is
separated from God. If any say that He passed through the Virgin
as through a conduit, and that He was not formed in her both divinely
and humanly (divinely, because without a human father; humanly, because
in accordance with the laws of gestation), he is in like manner
atheistic. If any assert that the Humanity was thus formed, and
the Deity subsequently added, he is condemned; for this is not a
generation of God, but an evasion of generation” (S. G. N. ad
Cled., Ep. i.) S. Thomas Aquinas explains the fitness of the
title thus: The Blessed Virgin could be denied to be the Mother
of God only if either His Humanity had been conceived and born before
That Man was the Son of God:—which was the position taken up by
Photinus; or else if the Humanity had not been assumed into the unity
of the Person (or Hypostasis) of the Son of God;—which was the
position of Nestorius. Both these positions are erroneous.
Therefore to deny that the Blessed Virgin is the Mother of God is
heretical (Summa, III.. xxxv. 4). In the text S. Gregory merely
means that the Godhead of our Lord was not derived from His Blessed
Mother, just as his Manhood was not derived from any man; but, as the
extract at the beginning of this Note shews, he would be the last to
take up the Nestorian notion, which was afterwards condemned at the
Council of Ephesus.