hearts are not changed, whose sins are yet upon them, as John says, "He that hateth his
brother is in darkness even until now?"1634 But if the sins of these men are remitted when
they join themselves in the close bonds of love to the good and just, through whom sins are
remitted in the Church, though they have been baptized by the wicked, so the sins of those
also are remitted who come from without and join themselves by the inner bond of peace
to the same framework of the body of Christ. Yet the baptism of Christ should be acknow-
ledged in both, and held invalid in none, whether before they are converted, though then
it profit them nothing, or after they are converted, that so it may profit them, as he says,
"Since they themselves, by withdrawing when they have lost their savor from the Church,
which is one, have become contrary to it, let that be done which is written, ‘The houses of
those that are opposed to the law must need be cleansed.’ And it therefore follows," he goes
on to say, "that those who have been polluted by being baptized by men opposed to Christ
487
should first be cleansed, and only then baptized." What then? Are thieves and murderers
not contrary to the law, which says, "Thou shalt not kill; thou shalt not steal?"1635 "They
must therefore needs be cleansed." Who will deny it? And yet not only those who are bap-
tized by such within the Church, but also those who, being such themselves, are baptized
without being changed in heart, are nevertheless exempt from further baptism when they
are so changed. So great is the force of the sacrament of mere baptism, that though we allow
that a man who has been baptized and continues to lead an evil life requires to be cleansed,
we yet forbid him to be any more baptized.
1634 1 John ii. 9.
1635 Ex. xx. 13, 15.
881
Chapter 14