of God, who knows infallibly to whom it may be even a benefit to be put to death.1654 He
therefore required me to show him one who, being a righteous man, had in the New Testa-
ment times put any one, even a criminal and impious man, to death.
Chap. V.
10. I then returned to the argument used in my former letter,1655 in which I laboured
to show that it was not right either for us to reproach them with atrocities of which some
of their party had been guilty, or for them to reproach us if any such deeds were found by
them to have been done on our side. For I granted that no example could be produced from
the New Testament of a righteous man putting any one to death; but I insisted that by the
example of our Lord Himself, it could be proved that the wicked had been tolerated by the
innocent. For His own betrayer, who had already received the price of His blood, He suffered
to remain undistinguished from the innocent who were with Him, even up to that last kiss
of peace. He did not conceal from the disciples the fact that in the midst of them was one
capable of such a crime; and, nevertheless, He administered to them all alike, without ex-
cluding the traitor, the first sacrament of His body and blood.1656 When almost all felt the
force of this argument, Fortunius attempted to meet it by saying, that before the Lord’s
Passion that communion with a wicked man did no harm to the apostles, because they had
not as yet the baptism of Christ, but the baptism of John only. When he said this, I asked
him to explain how it was written that Jesus baptized more disciples than John, though Jesus
Himself baptized not, but His disciples, that is to say, baptized by means of His disciples?1657
How could they give what they had not received (a question often used by the Donatists
themselves)? Did Christ baptize with the baptism of John? I was prepared to ask many other
questions in connection with this opinion of Fortunius; such as—how John himself was
interrogated as to the Lord’s baptizing, and replied that He had the bride, and was the
Bridegroom?1658 Was it, then, lawful for the Bridegroom to baptize with the baptism of him
who was but a friend or servant? Again, how could they receive the Eucharist if not previously
baptized? or how could the Lord in that case have said in reply to Peter, who was willing to
be wholly washed by Him, “He that is washed needeth not save to wash his feet, but is clean
every whit”?1659 For perfect cleansing is by the baptism, not of John, but of the Lord, if the
person receiving it be worthy; if, however, he be unworthy, the sacraments abide in him,
not to his salvation, but to his perdition. When I was about to put these questions, Fortunius
1654 Qui novit cui etiam prosit occidi.
1655 Let. XLIII. pp. 283, 284.
1656 Matt. xxvi. 20–28.
1657 John iv. 1, 2.
1658 John iii. 29.
1659 John xiii. 10.
652
To Eleusius, Glorius, and the Two Felixes