Baronius was of opinion that the Second Council of Nice was condemned by this
council; and before him Bellarmine had taught the same thing. But two things make me
dissent from their conclusion:
First. That as the history and acts of this council inform us that the legates of Pope
Hadrian (whom Ado in his chronology names Theophylact and Stephen) were present at
this council, it was not possible that the whole council was ignorant by what authority the
true Seventh Council was assembled at Nice, and what its decrees had been. For as this
Synod at Nice was assembled under the same Pontiff, the legates of that same Pontiff could
not have been ignorant of its authority and teaching. Therefore even if false rumours con-
cerning the Seventh Synod had been scattered about, as Genebrardus affirms (on what
foundation I know not), the Fathers of the Council of Frankfort could have been instructed
by the papal legates, and been given information and taught what were the writings of that
Seventh Council. Moreover since the celebration of that Nicene Council was an event most
celebrated and most widely published throughout the whole Church, it is not credible that
585
among the bishops of all France and Germany, assembled in this place, no single one was
found who had accurate information concerning the manner in which the Council of Nice
was assembled, or of how it had received the approval of the Supreme Pontiff. For as a
matter of fact, that error of adoring images as gods is rather an error of the Gentiles than of
any heretics or of any who profess the faith of Christ. Therefore in no way is it credible that
the fathers of the Council of Frankfort should have thought this, or rashly on account of
certain rumours have believed this; especially since at that time in no Church was there the
suspicion of any such error; and the bishops of the council were too pious and Catholic to
allow the suspicion that out of base enmity to the Orientals they were led to attribute error
to the fathers of the most sacred Council of Nice, or that they would have attached an
heretical sense to their decision.
Another reason is this; that the fathers of this council often made profession of acting
under the obedience of the Roman Pontiffs; and in the book Sacrosyllabus at the end, when
they gave sentence against the heretics, they subjoin these words: “The privilege of our lord
and father the Supreme Pontiff, Hadrian I. Pope of the most blessed See, being in all respects
maintained.” And this same principle the same fathers often professed in this council, that
they followed the tradition of their predecessors, and did not depart from their footsteps;
and that Charlemagne, who was present, at this council, in his letter to the Spanish bishops,
said that in the first place he had consulted the pontiff of the Apostolic See, what he thought
concerning the matter treated of in that council: and that a little further on he adds these
words: “I am united to the Apostolic see, and to the ancient Catholic traditions which have
come down from the beginnings of the new-born Church, with my whole mind, and with
complete alacrity of heart.”
1076
Excursus on the Council of Frankfort, A.D. 794.