The Teacher sighed gently at
these words of mine, and then said; Maybe these were the objections, or
such as these, that the Stoics and Epicureans collected at Athens made
in answer to the Apostle. I hear that Epicurus carried his theories in
this very direction. The framework of things was to his mind a
fortuitous ὡς τυχαία,
κ.τ.λ. It is better to connect
this directly with Epicurus himself, than to refer it, by bracketing
the preceding sentence (with Oehler), to his followers. Macrina infers
from the opinions known to her of Epicurus, what he must have said
about the human soul: i.e. that it was a bubble; and then what
his followers probably said. There is no evidence that Epicurus used
this actual figure: still Gregory may be recording his very
words.—Lucian (Charon, 68) enlarges on such a simile: and
his ὠκύμορον
φύσημα, as a
description of man, is reproduced by Gregory himself in Orat. de
Beatitud. p. 768 D. and mechanical affair, without a
Providence penetrating its operations; and, as a piece with this, he
thought that human life was like a bubble, existing only as long as the
breath within was held in by the enveloping substance τῷ
περιέχοντι. Sifanus takes this of the surrounding atmosphere. So also
Krabinger, “aere circumfuso,” just as above (182 A.) it
does certainly mean the air, and Wolf quotes a passage to that effect
from Marcus Antoninus and the present instance also. Still there is no
reason that it should not here mean the body of the man, which is as it
were a case retentive of the vital breath within; and the sense seems
to require it. As to the construction, although πομφόλυξ
is sometimes masculine in later Greek, yet it is much
more likely that περιταθέντος
(not περιτεθέντος
of the Paris Editt.) is the genitive absolute
with τοῦ
σώματος: τῶ
περιέχοντι
would then very naturally refer to this., inasmuch as our body was a mere membrane,
as it were, encompassing a breath; and that on the collapse of the
inflation the imprisoned essence was extinguished. To him the visible
was the limit of existence; he made our senses the only means of our
apprehension of things; he completely closed the eyes of his soul, and
was incapable of seeing anything in the intelligible and immaterial
world, just as a man, who is imprisoned in a cabin whose walls and roof
obstruct the view outside, remains without a glimpse of all the wonders
of the sky. Verily, everything in the universe that is seen to be an
object of sense is as an earthen wall, forming in itself a barrier
between the narrower souls and that intelligible world which is ready
for their contemplation; and it is the earth and water and fire alone
that such behold; whence comes each of these elements, in what and by
what they are encompassed, such souls because of their narrowness
cannot detect. While the sight of a garment suggests to any one the
weaver of it, and the thought of the shipwright comes at the sight of
the ship, and the hand of the builder is brought to the mind of him who
sees the building, these little souls gaze upon the world, but their
eyes are blind to Him whom all this that we see around us makes
manifest; and so they propound their clever and pungent doctrines about
the soul’s evanishment;—body from elements, and elements
from body, and, besides, the impossibility of the soul’s
self-existence (if it is not to be one of these elements, or lodged in
one); for if these opponents suppose that by virtue of the soul not
being akin to the elements it is nowhere after death, they must
propound, to begin with, the absence of the soul from the fleshly life
as well, seeing that the body itself is nothing but a concourse of
those elements; and so they must not tell us that the soul is to be
found there either, independently vivifying their compound. If it is
not possible for the soul to exist after death, though the
elements do, then, I say, according to this teaching our life as well
is proved to be nothing else but death. But if on the other hand they
do not make the existence of the soul now in the body a question for
doubt, how can they maintain its evanishment when the body is resolved
into its elements? Then, secondly, they must employ an equal audacity
against the God in this Nature too. For how can they assert that the
intelligible and immaterial Unseen can be dissolved and diffused into
the wet and the soft, as also into the hot and the dry, and so hold
together the universe in existence through being, though not of a
kindred nature with the things which it penetrates, yet not thereby
incapable of so penetrating them? Let them, therefore, remove from
their system the very Deity Who upholds the world.