‘When the winter,’
says he,
Liban. Orat. xviii. (Opera, i.
Reiske).
‘had lengthened the nights, the emperor made an attack on those
books which made the man of Palestine both God, and the Son of God: and
by a long series of arguments having proved that these writings, which
are so much revered by Christians, are ridiculous and unfounded, he has
evinced himself wiser and more skillful than the Tyrian
Porphyry. See above, I. 9.
old man. But may this Tyrian sage be propitious to me, and mildly bear
with what has been affirmed, seeing that he has been excelled by his
son!’ Such is the language of Libanius the Sophist. But I
confess, indeed, that he was an excellent rhetorician, but am persuaded
that had he not coincided with the emperor in religious sentiment, he
would not only have given expression to all that has been said against
him by Christians, but would have magnified every ground of censure as
naturally becomes a rhetorician. For while Constantius was alive he
wrote encomiums upon him; but after his death he brought the most
insulting and reproachful charges against him. So that if Porphyry had
been emperor, Libanius would certainly have preferred his books to
Julian’s: and had Julian been a mere sophist, he would have
termed him a very indifferent one, as he does Ecebolius in his
Epitaph upon Julian. Since then he has spoken in the spirit of a
pagan, a sophist, and the friend of him whom he lauded, we shall
endeavor to meet what he has advanced, as far as we are able. In the
first place he says that the emperor undertook to ‘attack’
these books during the long winter nights. Now to ‘attack’
means to make the writing of a confutation of them a task, as the
sophists commonly do in teaching the rudiments of their art; for he had
perused these books long before, but attacked them at this time. But
throughout the long contest into which he entered, instead of
attempting to disprove anything by sound reasoning, as Libanius
asserts, in the absence of truth he had recourse to sneers and
contemptuous jests, of which he was excessively fond; and thus he
sought to hold up to derision what is too firmly established to be
overthrown. For every one who enters into controversy with another,
sometimes trying to pervert the truth, and at others to conceal it,
falsifies by every possible means the position of his antagonist. And
an adversary is not satisfied with doing malignant acts against one
with whom he is at variance, but will speak against him also, and
charge upon the object of his dislike the very faults he is conscious
of in himself. That both Julian and Porphyry, whom Libanius calls the
‘Tyrian old man,’ took great delight in scoffing, is
evident from their own works. For Porphyry in his History of the
Philosophers has treated with ridicule the life of Socrates, the
most eminent of all the
philosophers, making such remarks on him as neither Melitus, nor
Anytus, his accusers, would have dared to utter; of Socrates, I say,
who was admired by all the Greeks for his modesty, justice, and other
virtues; whom Plato,
In his Crito, Phædo, Phædrus, and
Apology of Socrates. See also Xenophon’s Memorabilia of
Socrates and Symposium.
the most admirable among them, Xenophon, and the rest of the
philosophic band, not only honor as one beloved of God, but also are
accustomed to think of as having been endowed with superhuman
intelligence. And Julian, imitating his ‘father,’ displayed
a like morbidness of mind in his book, entitled The Cæsars,
wherein he traduces all his imperial predecessors, not sparing even
Mark the philosopher.
Marcus Aurelius.
Their own writings therefore show that they both took pleasure in
taunts and reviling; and I have no need of profuse and clever
expressions to do this; but what has been said is enough concerning
their mood in this respect. Now I write these things, using the oration
of each as witnesses respecting their dispositions, but of Julian in
particular, what Gregory of Nazianzus
Gregor. Nazianz. Orat. V. 23.
says in his Second Oration against the Pagans is in the
following terms: