We see then that by accepting the distinct statements of
the Paschal Letters of St. Athanasius and the preface, we obtain
a satisfactory chronological system in which the separate details
cohere well together, and which thus recommends itself. One great
objection which we formerly raised ourselves against the date 344 can
now be solved. It is certainly true that in 353 or 354 Pope
Librius wrote thus: “Eight years ago the Eusebian deputies,
Eudoxius and Martyrius (who came to the West with the formula
μακρόστικος),
refused to anathematize the Arian doctrine at Milan.” But
the Synod of Milan here alluded to, and placed about the year 345, was
not, as we before erroneously supposed, held before the Synod of
Sardica, but after it. We are somewhat less fortunate as regards
another difficulty. The Eusebians assembled at Philippopolis (the
pseudo-synod of Sardica) say, in their synodal letter:
“Bishop Asclepas of Gaza was deposed from his bishopric seventeen
years ago.” This deposition occurred at an Antiochian
synod. If we identified this synod with the well-known one of
330, by which Eustathius of Antioch also was overthrown, we should,
reckoning the seventeen years, have the year 346 or 347, in which to
place the writing of the Synodal Letter of Philippopolis, and therefore
the Synod of Sardica. There are, however, two ways of avoiding
this conclusion, either we must suppose that Asclepas has been already
deposed a year or so before the Antiochian Synod of 330; or that the
statement as to the number seventeen in the Latin translation of the
Synodal Letter of Philippopolis (for we no longer possess the original
text) is an error or slip of the pen. But in no case can this
Synodal Letter alter the fact that Athanasius was again in Alexandria
when he composed his Paschal Letter for the year 347, and that the
Synod of Sardica must therefore have been held several years
before.