Meanwhile the Eusebians were busy. In the new
Emperor Constantius, the Nicomedian found a willing patron: probably
his translation to the See of Constantinople falls at this time. It was
represented to the Emperor that the restoration of the exiled Bishops
in 337, and especially that of Athanasius, was against all
ecclesiastical order. Men deposed by a Synod of the Church had presumed
to return to their sees under the sanction of the secular authority.
This was technically true, but the proceedings at Tyre were regarded by
Athan. as depriving that Synod of any title to ecclesiastical authority
(pp. 104, 271). It is impossible to accept au pied de la lettre
the protests on either side against state interference with the Church:
both parties were willing to use it on their own side, and to protest
against its use by their opponents. Constantine had summoned As he had
previously referred the Donatist schism to the commission of Rome and
the Council of Arles. the Council of Nicæa, had (Soz. i. 17)
fixed the order of its proceedings, and had enforced its decisions by
civil penalties. The indignant rhetoric of Hist. Ar. 52 (p. 289)
might mutatis nominibus have been word for word the remonstrance
of a Secundus or Theonas against the great Ecumenical Synod of
Christendom. At Tyre, Jerusalem, and CP., the Eusebians had their turn,
and again at Antioch, 338–341. The Council of Sardica relied on
the protection of Constans, that of Philippopolis on Constantius. The
reign of the latter was the period of Arian triumph; that of Theodosius
secured authority to the Catholics. The only consistent opponents of
civil intervention in Church affairs were the Donatists in the West and
the Eunomians or later Arians in the East (with the obscure exception
of Secundus and Theonas, the original Arians cannot claim the
compliment paid by Fialon, p. 115, to their independence). To the
Donatists is due the classical protest against Erastianism, ‘Quid
Imperatori cum ecclesia’(D.C.B. i. 652). Believing, as the
present writer does, that the Donatist protest expresses a true
principle, and that the subjection of religion to the State is equally
mischievous with that of the State to the Church, it is impossible not
to regret these consequences of the conversion of Constantine. But
allowance must be made for the sanguine expectations with which the
astonishing novelty of a Christian Emperor filled men’s minds. It
was only as men came to realise that the civil sword might be drawn in
support of heresy that they began to reflect on the impropriety of
allowing to even a Christian Emperor a voice in Church councils.
Athanasius was the first to grasp this clearly. The voice of protest But they
complain, p. 104, §8, of coercion not of
Erastianism. sounds in the letter of the Egyptian Synod of
338–9; throughout his exiles he steadily regarded himself, and
was regarded by his flock, as the sole rightful Bishop of Alexandria,
and continued to issue his Easter Letters from first to last. At the
same time, it must be admitted that if he was right in returning to
Alexandria in 337 without restoration by a Synod, he could not
logically object to the return of Eusebius and Theognis (p. 104), who
had not been deposed at Nicæa, but banished by the Emperor. The
technical rights of Chrestus and Amphion (l. c.) were no
better than those of Gregory or George. The spiritual elevation of
Athanasius over the head and shoulders of his opponents is plain to
ourselves; we see clearly the moral contrast between the councils of
Rome and Antioch (340–41), of Sardica and Philippopolis (343), of
Alexandria (362) and Seleucia (359). But to men like the Eastern
‘conservatives’ the technical point of view necessarily
presented itself with great force, and in judging of their conduct we
must not assume that it was either ‘meaningless diabolism’
or deliberate sympathy with Arianism that led so many bishops of good
character to see in Athanasius and the other exiles contumacious
offenders against Church order. (I am quite unable to accept M.
Fialon’s sweeping verdict upon the majority of Oriental
bishops as ‘weak, vicious, more devoted to their own interests
than to the Church,’ &c., p. 116. He takes as literally exact
the somewhat turgid rhetorical complaints of Greg. Naz.)