man must know he has this qualification, in order to his being capable of conscientiously
attending it. If he judges that he has it, according to the best light he can obtain, on the most
careful examination, with the improvement of such helps as he can get, the advice of his
pastor, &c. he may be bound in conscience to attend. And the reason is this; Christians par-
taking of the Lord’s supper is not a matter of mere claim, or right and privilege, but a matter
of duty and obligation; being an affair wherein God has a claim and demand on us. And as
we ought to be careful, on the one hand, that we proceed on good grounds in taking to
ourselves a privilege, lest we take what we have no good claim to; so we should be equally
careful, on the other hand, to proceed on good grounds in what we withhold from another,
lest we do not withhold that from him which is his due, and which he justly challenges from
us. Therefore in a case of this complex nature, where a timing is both a matter of right or
privilege to us, and also a matter of obligation to another, or a right of his from us, the danger
of proceeding without right and truth is equal both ways; and consequently, if we cannot
be absolutely sure either way, here the best judgment we can form, after all proper endeavours
to know the truth, must govern and determine us; otherwise we shall designedly do that
whereby, according to our own judgment, we run the greatest risk; which is certainly contrary
to reason. If the question were only what a man has a right to, he might forbear till he were
sure: but the question is, not only whether he has right to attend the supper, but whether
God also has not a right to his attendance there? Supposing it were merely a privilege which
I am allowed but not commanded, in a certain specified case, then, supposing I am uncertain
whether that be the case with we or no, it will be safest to abstain. But supposing I am not
only forbidden to take it, unless that be the case with me, but positively commanded and
required to take it, if that be the case in fact, then it is equally dangerous to neglect on un-
certainties, as to take on uncertainties. In such a critical situation, a man must act according
to the best of his judgment on his case; otherwise he wilfully runs into that which he thinks
the greatest danger of the two.
Thus it is in innumerable cases in human life. I shall give one plain instance: A man
ought not to take upon him the work of the ministry, unless called to it in the providence
of God; for a man has no right to take this honour to himself unless called of God. Now let
us suppose a young man, of a liberal education, and well accomplished, to be at a loss
whether it is the will of God that he should follow the work of the ministry; and he examines
himself, and examines his circumstances, with great seriousness and solemn prayer, and
well considers and weighs the appearances in divine providence: and yet when he has done
all, he is not come to a proper certainty, that God calls him to this work; but however, it
looks so to him, according to the best light he can obtain, and the most careful judgment
he can form: now such an one appears obliged in conscience to give himself to this work. He
must by no means neglect it under a notion that he must not take this honour to himself, till
he knows he has a right to it; because, though it be indeed a privilege, yet it is not a matter
1852
OBJ. IX. If grace be required, it must be known.