covenant of grace, or a hearty embracing of the gospel: so that they who really reject Jesus
Christ, and dislike the gospel way of salvation in their hearts, and know that this is true of
themselves, may make the profession without lying and hypocrisy,” [on the principle that
they regard the sacrament as a converting ordinance, and partake of it with the hope of ob-
taining conversion.] “He formed a short profession for persons to make, in order to be ad-
mitted into the church, and to the sacrament, on these terms. Mr. Stoddard’s principle at
first made a great noise in the country; and he was opposed, as introducing something
contrary to the principles and the practice of almost all the churches in New England, and
the matter was publicly controverted between him and Dr. Increase Mather of Northampton.
However, through Mr. Stoddard’s great influence over the people of Northampton, it was
introduced there, though not without opposition: by degrees it spread very much among
ministers and people in that county, and in other parts of New England.”
At the settlement of Mr. Edwards, in 1727, this alteration in the qualifications required
for admission into the church had been in operation about twenty-two or three years; a
period during which the great body of the members of any church will be changed. This lax
plan of admission has no where been adopted by a church, for any considerable length of
time, without introducing a large proportion of members who are destitute of piety; and
although Mr. Stoddard was in other respects so faithful a minister, and so truly desirous of
the conversion and salvation of his people, there can be no doubt that such must have been
the result during so long a period in the church at Northampton.
“Mr. Edwards,” observes Dr. Hopkins, “had some hesitation about this matter when he
first settled at Northampton, but did not receive such a degree of conviction, as to prevent
his adopting it with a good conscience, for some years. But at length his doubts increased;
which put him upon examining it thoroughly, by searching the Scriptures, and reading such
books as were written on the subject. The result was, a full conviction that it was wrong,
and that he could not retain the practice with a good conscience. He was fully convinced
that to be a visible Christian, was to put on the visibility or appearance of a real Christian;
that a profession of Christianity was a profession of that wherein real Christianity consists;
and therefore that no person, who rejected Christ in his heart, could make such a profession
consistently with truth. And as the ordinance of the Lord’s supper was instituted for none
but visible professing Christians, that none but those who are real Christians have a right,
cxvi
in the sight of God, to come to that ordinance: and, consequently, that none ought to be
admitted thereto, who do not make a profession of real Christianity, and so can be received,
in a judgment of charity, as true friends to Jesus Christ.
“When Mr. Edwards’s sentiments were generally known in the spring of the year 1749,
it gave great offence, and the town was put into a great ferment; and before he was heard in
his own defence, or it was known by many what his principles were, the general cry was to
have him dismissed, as what would alone satisfy them. This was evident from the whole
236
CHAPTER XVI. Commencement of difficulties at Northampton