22 (continued). Ranking Him among these, according to the teaching of
Eusebius, and accounting Him such as the things which come into being
through Him, Arius and his fellows revolted from the truth, and used,
when they commenced this heresy, to go about with dishonest phrases
which they had got together; nay, up to this time some of them This
miserable procedure, of making sacred and mysterious subjects a matter
of popular talk and debate, which is a sure mark of heresy, had
received a great stimulus about this time by the rise of the
Anomœans. Eusebius’s testimony to the profaneness which
attended Arianism upon its rise will be given de Syn. 2, note 1.
The Thalia is another instance of it. S. Alexander speaks of the
interference, even judicial, in its behalf against himself, of
disobedient women, δι᾽
ἐντυχίας
γυναικαρίων
ἀτακτων ἃ
ἠπάτησαν, and of the busy and indecent gadding about of the
younger, ἐκ τοῦ
περιτροχάζειν
πᾶσαν ἀγυιὰν
ἀσέμνως.
ap. Theod. H. E. i. 3. p. 730, also p. 747; also of the
men’s buffoon conversation, p. 731. Socrates says that ‘in
the Imperial Court, the officers of the bedchamber held disputes with
the women, and in the city in every house there was a war of
dialectics.’ Hist. ii. 2. This mania raged especially in
Constantinople, and S. Gregory Naz. speaks of ‘Jezebels in as
thick a crop as hemlock in a field.’ Orat. 35. 3, cf.
de Syn. 13, n. 4. He speaks of the heretics as ‘aiming at
one thing only, how to make good or refute points of argument,’
making ‘every market-place resound with their words, and spoiling
every entertainment with their trifling and offensive talk.’
Orat. 27. 2. The most remarkable testimony of the kind though
not concerning Constantinople, is given by S. Gregory Nyssen, and often
quoted, ‘Men of yesterday and the day before, mere mechanics,
off-hand dogmatists in theology, servants too and slaves that have been
flogged, runaways from servile work, are solemn with us and
philosophical about things incomprehensible.…With such the whole
city is full; its smaller gates, forums, squares, thoroughfares; the
clothes-venders, the money-lenders, the victuallers. Ask about pence,
and he will discuss the Generate and Ingenerate; inquire the price of
bread, he answers, Greater is the Father, and the Son is subject; say
that a bath would suit you, and he defines that the Son is out of
nothing.’ t. 2. p. 898., when they fall in with boys in the market-place, question them,
not out of divine Scripture, but thus, as if bursting with ‘the
abundance of their heart Matt. xii. 34.;’—‘He who is, did He make
him who was not, from that which was [not], or him who was? therefore
did He make the Son, whereas He was, or whereas He was not This
objection is found in Alex. Ep. Encycl. 2. ὁ ὢν
θεὸς τὸν μὴ
ὄντα ἐκ τοῦ
μὴ ὄντος.
Again, ὄντα
γεγέννηκε ἢ
οὐκ ὄντα.
Greg. Orat. 29. 9. who answers it. Pseudo-Basil. contr.
Eunom. iv. p. 281. 2. Basil calls the question πολυθρύλλητον, contr. Eunom. ii. 14. It will be seen to be but
the Arian formula of ‘He was not before His generation,’ in
another shape; being but this, that the very fact of His being begotten
or a Son, implies a beginning, that is, a time when He was not: it
being by the very force of the words absurd to say that ‘God
begat Him that was,’ or to deny that ‘God begat Him
that was not.’ For the symbol, οὐκ ἦν πρὶν
γεννήθῃ,
vid. Excursus B. at the end of this Discourse.?’ And again, ‘Is the Unoriginate
one or two?’ and ‘Has He free will, and yet does not alter
at His own choice, as being of an alterable nature? for He is not as a
stone to remain by Himself unmoveable.’ Next they turn to silly
women, and address them in turn in this womanish language; ‘Hadst
thou a son before bearing? now, as thou hadst not, so neither was the
Son of God before His generation.’ In such language do the
disgraceful men sport and revel, and liken God to men, pretending to be
Christians, but changing God’s glory ‘into an image made
like to corruptible man Rom. i. 23, and
§2..’