When once pre-existence was
given up, the parts of the soul could be more closely united to each
other, because the lower and higher were in their beginning no longer
separated by a gulf of ages. Accordingly Gregory, reducing the three
parts of man which Origen had used to the simpler division into visible
and invisible (sensible and intelligible), dwells much upon the
intimate relation between the two and the mutual action of one upon the
other. Origen had retained the trichotomy of Plato which other Greek
Fathers also, with the sanction, as they supposed, of S. Paul
(1
Thess. v. 23), had adopted. ‘Body,’ ‘soul,’ and
‘spirit,’ or Plato’s ‘body,’
‘unreasoning’ and ‘reasoning soul,’ had helped
Origen to explain how the last, the pre-existent soul (the spirit, or
the conscience Comment. in Rom. ii. 9, p.
486., as he sometimes calls it) could ever
have come to live in the flesh. The second, the soul proper, is as it
were a mediating ground on which the spirit can meet the flesh. The
celestial mind, ‘the real man fallen from on high,’ rules
by the power of conscience or of will over this soul, where the merely
animal functions and the natural appetites reside; and through this
soul over the body. How the celestial mind can act at all upon this
purely animal soul which lies between it and the body, Origen leaves
unexplained. But this division was necessary for him, in order to
represent the spirit as remaining itself unchanged in its heavenly
nature, though weakened by its long captivity in the body. The middle
soul (in which he sometimes places the will) is the scene of
contamination and disorder; the spirit is free, it can always rejoice
at what is well done in the soul, and yet is not touched by the evil in
it; it chooses, convicts, and punishes. Such was Origen’s
psychology. But an intimate connexion both in birth and growth between
all the faculties of man is one of Gregory’s most
characteristic thoughts, and he gave up this trichotomy, which was
still, however, retained by some Greek fathers, and adopted the simpler
division mentioned above in order more clearly and concisely to show
the mutual play of spirit and body upon each other. There was soon,
too, another reason why this trichotomy should be suspected. It was a
second time made the vehicle of error. Apollinaris adopted it, in order
to expound that the Divine Λόγος took the
place, in the tripartite soul of Christ, of the ‘reasonable
soul’ or spirit of other men. Gregory, in pressing for a simpler
treatment of man’s nature, thus snatched a vantage-ground from a
sagacious enemy. His own psychology is only one instance of a tendency
which runs through the whole of his system, and which may indeed be
called the dominating thought with which he approached every question;
he views each in the light of form and matter; spirit penetrating and
controlling body, body answering to spirit and yet at the same time
supplying the nutriment upon which the vigour and efficacy of spirit,
in this world at least, depends. This thought underlies his view of the
material universe and of Holy Scripture, as well as of man’s
nature. With regard to the last he says, ‘the intelligible cannot be
realized in body at all, except it be commingled with sensation;’
and again, ‘as there can be no sensation without a material
substance, so there can be no exercise of the power of thought without
sensation De
Hom. Op. c. viii.; De An. et Resurr.
205..’ The spiritual or intelligent part of
man (which he calls by various names, such as ‘the inner
man,’ the ψυχὴ λογικὴ,
νοῦς or διάνοια, τὸ
ζωοποιὸν αἴτιον, or simply ψυχὴ as throughout
the treatise On the Soul), however alien in its essence from the
bodily and sentient part, yet no sooner is united with this earthly
part than it at once exerts power over it. In fact it requires this
instrument before it can reach its perfection. ‘Seeing, then, man
is a reasoning animal of a certain kind, it was necessary that the body
should be prepared as an instrument appropriate to the needs of his
reason De
Hom. Op. c. viii..’ So closely has this reason been united
with the senses and the flesh that it performs itself the functions of
the animal part; it is the ‘mind’ or ‘reason’
itself that sees, hears, &c.; in fact the exercise of mind depends
on a sound state of the senses and other organs of the body; for a sick
body cannot receive the ‘artistic’ impressions of the mind
and, so, the mind remains inoperative. This is enough to show how far
Gregory had got from pre-existence and the ‘fall into the prison
of the flesh.’