Book v.] ARNOBIUS ADVERSUS GENTES. 257
earth, and unites with Orcus to bring forth fruit. In like
manner in the other stories also one thing indeed is said, but
something else is understood; and under a commonplace
openness of expression there lurks a secret doctrine, and a
dark profundity of mystery.
33. These are all quirks, as is evident, and quibbles with
which they are wont to bolster up weak cases before a jury ;
nay, rather, to speak more truly, they are pretences, such as
are used in’ sophistical reasonings, by which not the truth
is sought after, but always the image, and appearance, and
shadow of the truth. For because it is shameful and unbe-
coming to receive as true the correct accounts, you have had
recourse” to this expedient, that one thing should be substi-
tuted for another, and that what was in itself shameful should,
in being explained, be forced into the semblance of decency.
But what is it to us whether other senses and other meanings
underlie [these] vain stories? For we who assert that the
gods are treated by you wickedly and impiously, need only?
receive what is written, what is said,* and need not care as to
what is kept secret, since the insult to the deities consists not
in the idea hidden in its meanings,’ but in what is signified
by the words as they stand out. And yet, that we may not.
seem unwilling to examine what you say, we ask this first of
you, if only you will bear with us, from whom have you
learned, or by whom has it been made known, either that
these things were written allegorically, or that they should
be understood in the same way? Did the writers summon
you to [take] counsel [with them]? or did you lie hid in
their bosoms at the time? when they put one thing for
another, without regard to truth? Then, if they chose, from
1 Lit., ** colours of.”
* The Ms. and both Roman edd. read indecorum est, which leaves the
sentence incomplete. LB., followed by later edd., proposed decursum
est, as above (Oehler, inde d.—''from these recourse has been had"),
the other conjectures tending to the same meaning.
3 ** We need only ;" lit., ‘it is enough for us to.”
* Lit., ** heard."
5 Lit., * in the obscure mind of senses."
$ “Or at the time,” aut tum, the correction of LB. for the us. sutum.
ARNOB. R