And in this we follow no other authority than Leo
himself, who speaks thus in his letter to Theodoret: “What
God had before decreed by our ministry, he confirmed by the
irreversible assent of the whole brotherhood, to shew that what was
first put forth in form by the First See of all, and then received by
the judgment of the whole Christian world, really proceeded from
himself.” Here is a decree, as Baronius says, but not as
Bellarmine says, an instruction: here is a judgment of the whole
world upon a decree of the Apostolic See. He proceeds:
“For in order that the consent of other sees to that which the
Lord of all appointed to preside over the rest might not appear
flattery, nor any other adverse suspicion creep in, persons were at
first found who doubted concerning our judgments.” And not
only heretics, but even the Fathers of the council themselves, as the
acts bear witness. Here the
First See shews a fear of flattery, if doubt about its judgments were
forbidden. Moreover, “The truth itself likewise is both
more clearly conspicuous, and more strongly maintained, when after
examination confirms what previous faith had taught.” Here
in plain words he speaks of an examination by the council, de
fide, not by himself, as they wretchedly object, but of that faith
which the decretal letter set forth. And at length that same
letter is issued as the Rule, but confirmed by the assent of the
universal holy Council, or as he had before said, after that it is
confirmed by the irreversible assent of the whole Brotherhood.
Out of this expression of that great Pontiff, the Gallican clergy drew
theirs, that in questions of faith the judgment is, what Tertullian
calls, “not to be altered;” what Leo calls, “not to
be reconsidered,” only when the assent of the Church is
added.