that in saying that “the soul, appointed, after the entrance of sin, to occupy an inferior body,
does not govern its body absolutely according to its own free will,” I stated what is true; for
“the flesh lusteth against the spirit,2573 and in this we groan, being burdened,”2574 and “the
corruptible body weighs down the soul,”2575—in short, who can enumerate all the evils
arising from the infirmity of the flesh, which shall assuredly cease when “this corruptible
shall have put on incorruption,” so that “that which is mortal shall be swallowed up of
life”?2576 In that future condition, therefore, the soul shall govern its spiritual body with
absolute freedom of will; but in the meantime its freedom is not absolute, but conditioned
by the laws of the universe, according to which it is fixed, that bodies having experienced
birth experience death, and having grown to maturity decline in old age. For the soul of the
first man did, before the entrance of sin, govern his body with perfect freedom of will, al-
though that body was not yet spiritual, but animal; but after the entrance of sin, that is, after
sin had been committed in that flesh from which sinful flesh was thenceforward to be
propagated, the reasonable soul is so appointed to occupy an inferior body, that it does not
govern its body with absolute freedom of will. That infant children, even before they have
committed any sin of their own, are partakers of sinful flesh, is, in my opinion, proved by
their requiring to have it healed in them also, by the application in their baptism of the
remedy provided in Him who came in the likeness of sinful flesh. But even those who do
not acquiesce in this view have no just ground for taking offence at the sentence quoted
from my book; for it is certain, if I am not mistaken, that even if the infirmity be the con-
sequence not of sin, but of nature, it was at all events only after the entrance of sin that
bodies having this infirmity began to be produced; for Adam was not created thus, and he
did not beget any offspring before he sinned.
7. Let my critics, therefore, seek other passages to censure, not only in my other more
hastily published works, but also in these books of mine on Free Will. For I by no means
deny that they may in this search discover opportunities of conferring a benefit on me; for
if the books, having passed into so many hands, cannot now be corrected, I myself may,
being still alive. Those words, however, so carefully selected by me to avoid committing
myself to any one of the four opinions or theories regarding the soul’s origin, are liable to
censure only from those who think that my hesitation as to any definite view in a matter so
obscure is blameworthy; against whom I do not defend myself by saying that I think it right
to pronounce no opinion whatever on the subject, seeing that I have no doubt either that
the soul is immortal—not in the same sense in which God is immortal, who alone hath im-
2573 Gal. v. 17.
2574 2 Cor. v. 4.
2575 Wisd. ix. 15.
2576 1 Cor. xv. 53.
1055
To Marcellinus