darkness, or rather from the members of your god in subjection and bondage; and your
World-holder, who has in his hand the remains of these members, and who bewails the
capture and bondage and pollution of the rest; and your giant Atlas, who keeps up the
World-holder on his shoulders, lest he should from weariness throw away his burden, and
so prevent the completion of the final imitation of the mass of darkness, which is to be the
last scene in your drama;—these and countless other absurdities are not represented in
painting or sculpture, or in any explanation; and yet you believe and worship things which
have no existence, while you taunt the Christians with being credulous for believing in
realities with a faith which pacifies the mind under its influence. The objects of your worship
can be shown to have no existence by many proofs, which I do not bring forward here, be-
cause, though I could without difficulty discourse philosophically on the construction of
the world, it would take too long to do so here. One proof suffices. If these things are real,
God must be subject to change, and corruption, and contamination; a supposition as blas-
phemous as it is irrational. All these things, therefore, are vain, and false, and unreal. Thus
you are much worse than those Pagans, with whom all are familiar, and who still preserve
traces of their old customs, of which they themselves are ashamed; for while they worship
things which are not gods, you worship things which do not exist.
10. If you think that your doctrines are true because they are unlike the errors of the
Pagans, and that we are in error because we perhaps differ more from you than from them,
you might as well say that a dead man is in good health because he is not sick; or that good
health is undesirable, because it differs less from sickness than from death. Or if the Pagans
should be viewed in many cases as rather dead than sick, you might as well praise the ashes
in the tomb because they have no longer the human shape, as compared with the living
body, which does not differ so much from a corpse as from ashes. It is thus we are reproached
for having more resemblance to the dead body of Paganism than to the ashes of Manichæism.
But in division, it often happens that a thing is placed in different classes, according to the
point of resemblance on which the division proceeds. For instance, if animals are divided
into those that fly and those that cannot fly, in this division men and beasts are classed to-
257
gether as distinct from birds, because they are both unable to fly. But if they are divided
into rational and irrational, beasts and birds are classed together as distinct from men, for
they are both destitute of reason. Faustus did not think of this when he said: There are in
fact only two sects, the Gentiles and ourselves, for we are directly opposed to them in our
belief. The opposition he means is this, that the Gentiles believe in a single principle,
whereas the Manichæans believe also in the principle of the race of darkness. Certainly,
according to this division we agree in general with the Pagans. But if we divide all who have
a religion into those who worship one God and those who worship many gods, the
Manichæans must be classed along with the Pagans, and we along with the Jews. This is
another distinction, which may be said to make only two sects. Perhaps you will say that
438
Faustus repels the charge of sun-worship, and maintains that while the Manichæans…