LETTERS CXXIIL, CXXIV.
239
clares that he does not know whether the
Holy Spirit is created or uncreated,1 he has later on given his own opinion that except
God the Father alone there is nothing uncre-
ated. " The Son," he states, " is inferior to the Father, inasmuch as He is second and the
Father first ; and the Holy Spirit which dwells in all the saints is inferior to the Son. In the
same way the power of the Father is greater
than that of the Son and of the Holy Spirit.
Likewise the power of the Son is greater than
that of the Holy Spirit, and as a consequence
the Holy Spirit in its turn has greater virtue
than other things called holy."2 3. Then, when he comes to deal with rational
creatures and to describe their lapse into
earthly bodies as due to their own negligence,
he goes on to say : " Surely it argues great negligence and sloth for a soul so far to
empty itself as to fall into sin and allow it-
self to be tied to the material body of an
unreasoning brute ; " and in a subsequent
passage : " These reasonings induce me to suppose that it is by their own free act that
some are numbered with God's saints and ser- vants, and that it was through their own fault
that others fell from holiness into such negli-
gence that they were changed into forces of
an opposite kind." : He maintains that after every end a fresh beginning springs forth and
an end from each beginning, and that whole-
sale variation is possible ; so that one who is
now a human being may in another world be-
come a demon, while one who by reason of his
negligence is now a demon may hereafter be
placed in a more material body and thus be-
come a human being.4 So far does he carry this transforming process that on his theory
an archangel may become the devil and the
devil in turn be changed back into an arch-
angel. " Such as have wavered or faltered but have not altogether fallen shall be made
subject, for rule and government and guidance,
to better things — to principalities and powers, to thrones and dominations ; and of these
perhaps another human race will be formed, when in the words of Isaiah there shall be
' new heavens and a new earth.' 6 But such as
have not deserved to return through humanity to their former estate shall become the devil
and his angels, demons of the worst sort ; and
according to what they have done shall have
special duties assigned to them in particular
worlds." Moreover, the very demons and! rulers of darkness in any world or worlds, if ;
they are willing to turn to better things, may !
become human beings and so come back to ,
their first beginning. That is to say, after
1 F. P., I. Preface. 4.
1 F. P.. I. 3,5. The words are omitted by Rufinus.
1 F. P., I. 5, 5. « F. P., I. 6, 2. * Isa. Ixv. 17.
they have borne the discipline of punishment
and torture for a longer or a shorter time in
human bodies, they may again reach the
angelic pinnacles from which they have fallen.
Hence it may be shewn that we men may
change into any other reasonable beings, and
that not once only or on emergency but time
after time ; we and angels shall become de-
mons if we neglect our duty ; and demons, if
they will take to themselves virtues, may at- tain to the rank of angels.
4. Bodily substances too are to pass away
utterly or else at the end of all things will be-
come highly rarified like the sky and aether and other subtle bodies. It is clear that these
principles must affect the writer's view of the resurrection. The sun also and the moon and
the rest of the constellations are alive. Nay
more ; as we men by reason of our sins are
enveloped in bodies material and sluggish ; so
the lights of heaven have for like reasons re-
ceived bodies more or less luminous, and
demons have been for more serious faults
clothed with starry frames. This, he argues,
is the view of the apostle who writes : — " the creation has been subjected to vanity and shall
be delivered for the revealing of the sons of
God." That it may not be supposed that I am imputing to him ideas of my own I shall
give his actual words. " At the end and con-
summation of the world," he writes, " when souls and beings endowed with reason shall be
released from prison by the Lord" they will move slowly or fly quickly according as they
have previously been slothful or energetic. And as all of them have free will and are free
to choose virtue or vice, those who choose the
latter will be much worse off than they now are. But those who choose the former will
improve their condition. Their movements
and decisions in this direction or in that will
determine their various futures ; whether, that
is, angels are to become men or demons, and
whether demons are to become men or angels." Then after adducing various arguments in
support of his thesis and maintaining that
while not incapable of virtue the devil has
yet not chosen to be virtuous, he has finally
reasoned with much diffuseness that an angel,
a human soul, and a demon — all according to
him of one nature but of different wills — may
in punishment for great negligence or folly be
transformed into brutes. Moreover, to avoid
the agony of punishment and the burning flame
the more sensitive may choose to become low
organisms, to dwell in water, to assume the
shape of this or that animal ; so that we have
reason to fear a metamorphosis not only into
four-footed things but even into fishes. Then,
1 Rom. viii. 19-21, R.V.