393. But at the beginning of the second period a certain
Aterbius came to Jerusalem and spread suspicion and alarm of heresy.
Jerome, perhaps weakly, “gave him satisfaction” as to his
faith (Apol. iii. 33, Vol. iii. 535), while by John and Rufinus he was
treated as a busybody (id.). This produced the first
estrangement, which was greatly increased by the visit of Epiphanius in
the following year. The scenes which followed may be read in
Jerome’s treatise, “Against John of Jerusalem” (430)
and in Epiphanius’ letter translated by Jerome (83–85).
Epiphanius was popular at Jerusalem, and after a scene in the church,
in which he preached against Origenism and John against
Anthropomorphism, a breach was made between the two prelates.
Epiphanius came to stay at Bethlehem, and spoke of John as well nigh a
heretic. John spoke of Epiphanius as “that old tard” (430).
The monks of Bethlehem took part with Epiphanius; and he, to prevent
their being deprived of clerical
ministration by Bishop John, ordained Jerome’s brother Paulinian
at his monastery of Ad in the diocese of Eleutheropolis. He was then
only thirty years old, and was ordained against his will, and with the
employment of force and even gagging (83). Epiphanius, returning to
Cyprus, wrote to John a letter explaining his conduct (83–89)
which was translated by Jerome, but which did little to allay the
strife. John placed the monasteries, at least partially, under an
interdict (446–447), and appealed to Rome and to Alexandria, and
afterwards to Rufinus, the Pretorian Prefect at Constantinople (174,
447). Theophilus at first took John’s side vehemently; but the
mission of his confidant Isidore miscarried (444, 445), and after some
time his views of the situation changed and he made peace with Jerome
and his friends.