Meanwhile, the anti-Nicene reaction was being
skilfully fostered by the strategy of Eusebius of Nicomedia. Within a
year of the election of Athanasius we find him restored to imperial
favour, and at once the assault upon the Nicene strongholds begins. The
controversy between Marcellus and Eusebius of Cæsarea
(supra, p. xxxv.), appears to have begun later, but the latter
was already, in conjunction with his friend Paulinus of Tyre and with
Patrophilus, at theological war with Eustathius of Antioch. A synod of
Arian and reactionary bishops assembled at Antioch, and deposed the
latter on the two charges (equally de rigueur in such cases) of
Sabellianism and immorality. Backed by a complaint (possibly founded on
fact) that he had indiscreetly repeated a current tale (p. 271, n. 2)
concerning Helena, the Emperor’s mother, the sentence of the
council had the full support of the civil arm, and Eustathius lost his
see for ever. Although he lived till about 358, no council ventured to
‘restore’ him (discussed by Gwatkin, pp. 73, 74, note), but
the Christian public of Antioch violently resented his extrusion, and a
compact body of the Church-people steadily refused to recognise any
other bishop during, and even after, his lifetime (infr. p.
481). Asclepas of Gaza was next disposed of, then Eutropius of
Hadrianople, and many others (names, p. 271). Meanwhile everything was
done to foment disturbance in Egypt. The Meletians had been stirring
ever since the death of Alexander, and Eusebius was not slow to use
such an opportune lever. The object in view was two-fold, the
restoration of Arius to communion in Alexandria, without which the
moral triumph of the reaction would be unachieved, and the extrusion of
Athanasius. Accordingly a fusion took place Soz. ii.
21, 22: the account is not very clear; probably there was a gradual
approximation, the first step being the Meletian support of the Arian
Theonas against Athanasius in 328, if the view suggested above is
correct. between
the Arians of Egypt and the
Meletians, now under the leadership of John ‘Arcaph,’ whom
Meletius on his death-bed had consecrated as his successor against the
terms of the Nicene settlement. At any rate, the Meletians were
attached to the cause by Eusebius by means of large promises. At the
same time (330?) Eusebius, having obtained the recall of Arius from
exile, wrote to Athanasius requesting him to admit Arius and his
friends (Euzoius, Pistus, &c.) to communion; the bearer of the
letter conveyed the assurance of dire consequences in the event of his
non-compliance (p. 131). Athanasius refused to admit persons convicted
of heresy at the Ecumenical Council. This brought a letter from the
Emperor himself, threatening deposition by an imperial mandate unless
he would freely admit ‘all who should desire it;’—a
somewhat sweeping demand. Athanasius replied firmly and, it would seem,
with effect, that ‘the Christ-opposing heresy had no fellowship
with the Catholic Church.’ Thereupon Eusebius played what proved
to be the first card of a long suit. A deputation of three Meletian
bishops arrived at the Palace with a complaint. Athanasius had, they
said, levied a precept (κανών) upon Egypt for Church
expenses: they had been among the first victims of the exaction.
Luckily, two Presbyters of Alexandria were at court, and were able to
disprove the charge, which accordingly drew a stern rebuke upon its
authors. Constantine wrote to Athanasius summoning him to an audience,
probably with the intention of satisfying himself as to other
miscellaneous accusations which were busily ventilated at this date,
e.g., that he was too young (cf. p. 133) when elected bishop, that he
had governed with arrogance and violence, that he used magic (this
charge was again made 30 years later, Ammian. xv. 7), and subsidised
treasonable persons. Athanasius accordingly started for court, as it
would seem, late in 330 (see Letter 3, p. 512 sq.). His
visit was successful, but matters went slowly; Athanasius himself had
an illness, which lasted a long time, and upon his recovery the winter
storms made communication impossible. Accordingly, his Easter letter
for 332 (Letter 4) was sent unusually late—apparently in
the first navigable weather of that year—and Athanasius reached
home, after more than a year’s absence Fest.
Ind. iii. The Index is of course right in giving
330–331 as the year of his departure for Nicomedia, but makes a
slip in assigning his absence as the cause of delay in the despatch of
the Letter for that year instead of for the following one. See
p. 512 note 1., when
Lent was already half over.