One thing, however, that he says
is true: that his own teaching, not the Catholic teaching, is summed up
so. Indeed any one who reflects can easily see the impiety of his
statement. It will not be out of place now to discuss in detail what
his intention is in ascribing to the being of the Father alone the
highest degree of that which is supreme and proper, while not admitting
that the being of the Son and of the Holy Ghost is supreme and proper.
For my part I think that it is a prelude to his complete denial of the
‘being’ of the Only-begotten and of the Holy Ghost, and
that this system of his is secretly intended to effect the setting
aside of all real belief in their personality, while in appearance and
in mere words confessing it. A moment’s reflection upon his
statement will enable any one to perceive that this is so. It does not
look like one who thinks that the Only-begotten and the Holy Ghost
really exist in a distinct personality to be very particular about the
names with which he thinks the greatness of Almighty God should be
expressed. To grant the fact i.e. of
the equality of Persons., and then go into
minute distinctions about the appropriate phrases i.e.
for the Persons.
would be indeed consummate folly: and so in ascribing a being that is
in the highest degree supreme and proper only to the Father, he makes
us surmise by this silence respecting the other two that (to him) they
do not properly exist. How can that to which a proper being is denied
be said to really exist? When we deny proper being to it, we must
perforce affirm of it all the opposite terms. That which cannot be
properly said is improperly said, so that the demonstration of its not
being properly said is a proof of its not really subsisting: and it is
at this that Eunomius seems to aim in introducing these new names into
his teaching. For no one can say that he has strayed from ignorance
into some silly fancy of separating, locally, the supreme from that
which is below, and assigning to the Father as it were the peak of some
hill, while he seats the Son lower down in the hollows. No one is so
childish as to conceive of differences in space, when the intellectual
and spiritual is under discussion. Local position is a property of the
material: but the intellectual and immaterial is confessedly removed
from the idea of locality. What, then, is the reason why he says that
the Father alone has supreme being? For one can hardly think it is from
ignorance that he wanders off into these conceptions, being one who, in
the many displays he makes, claims to be wise, even “making
himself overwise,” as the Holy Scripture forbids us to do Eccles. vii.
16..