Elucidations.
————————————
I.
(The Shepherd of Hermas, p. 85.)
Here, and in chap. xx. below, Tertullian’s
rabid utterances against the
Shepherd
may be balanced by what he
had said, less unreasonably, in his better mood.
999
Now he refers to the
Shepherd’s
(ii. 1)
1000
view of
pardon, even to adulterers. But surely it might be objected even
more plausibly against “the Shepherd,” whom he prefers, in
common with all Christians, as see
John viii. 1–11
, which I take to be canonical
Scripture. A curious question is suggested by what he says of the
figure of the Good Shepherd portrayed on the chalice: Is this
irony
, as if the figure so familiar from illustrations of the
catacombs must be meant for the
Shepherd
of Hermas?
Regarding all pictures as idolatrous, he may intend to intimate that
adultery (=idolatry) was thus symbolized.
II.
(Clasping the knees of all, p. 86.)
Here is a portrait of the early penitential discipline
sufficiently terrible, and it conforms to the apostolic pictures of the
same. “Tell it unto the Church,” says our Lord
(
Matt. xviii. 17
). In
1 Cor. v. 4
the apostle (“present in
spirit”) gives judgment, but the whole Church is “gathered
together.” In
James v. 16
the “confession to
one
another
” seems to refer to this public discipline, as also
the prayer for
healing
enjoined on one another. St.
Chrysostom, however, reflecting the discipline of his day, in which
great changes were made, says, on
Matt. xviii. 17
, unless it be a gloss, “
Dic
Ecclesiæ
id est
Præsidibus
=
προεδρευούσιν
.”
(Tom. vii. p. 536, ed. Migne.)
III.
(Remedial discipline, p. 87.)
Powerfully as Tertullian states his view of this
apostolic “delivering unto Satan” as for final perdition,
it is not to be gainsaid that (
1 Cor. v. 5
) the object was salvation and hope,
“that the spirit may be saved in the day of the Lord
Jesus.” Thus, the power of Satan to inflict bodily
suffering (
Job ii.
6
), when divinely permitted,
is recognised under the Gospel (
Luke xiii. 16; 2 Cor. xii. 7
). The remedial mercy of trials and
sufferings may be inferred when providentially occurring.
IV.
(Personally upon Peter, p. 99.)
See what has been said before. But note our
author (now writing against the Church, and as a Montanist) has no idea
that the
personal
prerogative of St. Peter had descended to any
bishop. More when we come to Cyprian, and see vol. iii. p. 630,
this series.
999
On Prayer
, vol.
iii. cap. xvi. p. 686,
supra
, where he speaks respectfully.
1000
Vol. ii. p. 22 (also
p. 43), this series.