However, they who are
enlightened in Eunomius’ fashion pass the Son by, and are carried
in their reasonings beyond Him, seeking eternal life in Him Who is
contemplated as outside and apart from the Only-begotten. What ought
one to say to such evils as these,—save whatever calls forth
lamentation and weeping? Alas, how can we groan over this wretched and
pitiable generation, bringing forth a crop of such deadly mischiefs? In
days of yore the zealous Jeremiah bewailed the people of Israel, when
they gave an evil consent to Jehoiakim who led the way to idolatry, and
were condemned to captivity under the Assyrians in requital for their
unlawful worship, exiled from the sanctuary and banished far from the
inheritance of their fathers. Yet more fitting does it seem to me that
these lamentations be chanted when the imitator of Jehoiakim draws away
those whom he deceives to this new kind of idolatry, banishing them
from their ancestral inheritance,—I mean the Faith. They too, in
a way corresponding to the Scriptural record, are carried away captive to
Babylon from Jerusalem that is above,—that is from the Church of
God to this confusion of pernicious doctrines,—for Altering Oehler’s punctuation. Babylon means “confusion.” And
even as Jehoiakim was mutilated, so this man, having voluntarily
deprived himself of the light of the truth, has become a prey to the
Babylonian despot, never having learned, poor wretch, that the Gospel
enjoins us to behold eternal life alike in the Father, and the Son, and
the Holy Ghost, inasmuch as the Word has thus spoken concerning the
Father, that to know Him is life eternal Cf.
S. John xvii. 3, and
concerning the Son, that every one that believeth on Him hath eternal
life Cf.
S. John iii. 36, and concerning the Holy Spirit, that to Him
that hath received His grace it shall be a well of water springing up
unto eternal life Cf.
S. John iv. 14. Accordingly every
one that yearns for eternal life when he has found the Son,—I
mean the true Son, and not the Son falsely so called—has found in
Him in its entirety what he longed for, because He is life and hath
life in Himself Cf.
S. John v. 26. But this man, so
subtle in mind, so keen-sighted of heart, does not by his extreme
acuteness of vision discover life in the Son, but, having passed Him
over and left Him behind as a hindrance in the way to that for which he
searches he there seeks eternal life where he thinks the true Life not
to be! What could we conceive more to be abhorred than this for
profanity, or more melancholy as an occasion of lamentation? But that
the charge of Sabellianism and Montanism should be repeatedly urged
against our doctrines, is much the same as if one should lay to our
charge the blasphemy of the Anomœans. For if one were carefully to
investigate the falsehood of these heresies, he would find that they
have great similarity to the error of Eunomius. For each of them
affects the Jew in his doctrine, admitting neither the Only-begotten
God nor the Holy Spirit to share the Deity of the God Whom they call
“Great,” and “First.” For Whom Sabellius calls
God of the three names, Him does Eunomius term unbegotten: but neither
contemplates the Godhead in the Trinity of Persons. Who then is really
akin to Sabellius let the judgment of those who read our argument
decide. Thus far for these matters.