CONCERNING THE BAPTISM OF HERETICS. 213 Marcellusof Zama1 said: Since sinsare not remittedsave in the baptism of the church,he who does not baptizea hereticholdscommunion with a sinner. Irenams of Ululi3 said: If the church doesnot baptizea heretic,for the reason thathe issaidto be alreadybaptized, itisthe greaterheresy. Donatus of Cibaliana*said: I know one church and her one baptism. If there is any who says that the grace of baptism is with heretics,he must firstshow and prove that the church isamong them. Zosimus of Tharassa4said:When a revelationof thetruth ismade, leterrorgiveplaceto truth;becausePeteralso,who previouslycircumcised,yieldedto Paul when he preached the truth. Julianus of Telepte5said: It is written," No man can receiveanythingunlessithave been givenhim from heaven."0 If heresyisfrom heaven,itcan alsogivebaptism. Faustus of Timida Kegia7 said: Let not them who arein favour of hereticsflatterthemselves. He who interfereswith the baptism of the church on behalfof heretics,makes them Christians,and us heretics. Geminius of Furni8 said: Some of our colleaguesmay prefer hereticstothemselves,theycannot tous ; and therefore what we have once determinedwe maintain— thatwe baptize those who come to us from the heretics. Kogatianus of Nova" said: Christinstitutedthe church ; the Devil,heresy. How can the synagogue of Satan have the baptism of Christ? Therapius of Bulla10said: He who concedesand betrays 1 A cityofNumidia; thesceneofHannibal'soverthrowby Scipio. 3 " Usilla,"a cityofByzacena. 3 Possibly" Ccrbaliana" inByzacena. * A cityofNumidia. 5 A cityofNumidiaByzaccnas. 0 Johniii.27. 7 A cityofZeugitana; someread" Tumida." 8 A cityofZeugitana. ' A cityofMauritaniaCanadensis.FellobservesthatinNumidiaare many citiesofthenameof" Nova" or" Noba." 10A cityofZeugitana.Thereweretwocitiesofthename— BovKkctpU,