This History takes up
the narrative from the admission of Arius to communion at the
‘dedication’ synod of Jerusalem (adjourned Council of Tyre)
in 335, as described in Apol. c. Ar. 84. It has been commonly
assumed from its abrupt beginning (the ταῦτα, referring to an antecedent
narrative) that the History has lost its earlier chapters, which
contained the story of Arianism ab ovo. Montfaucon suggests in
fact that the copyists omitted the first chapters on account of their
identity in substance with the great Apology. But this seems to require
reconsideration. If the alleged missing chapters were different i.e.
slight modifications excepted, see Montf. in Migne, P.G. xxv.
318, note 46, and 389, note 60. in form from the second part of the Apology,
they would not have been omitted: for such repetitions of the same
matter in other words are very frequent in the works of Athanasius: but
if they were identical in form, they are not lost, and the conclusion
is that the History was written with the express intention of
continuing the Apology. The customary inference from the abrupt
commencement of the History may be dismissed with a non
sequitur. Such a commencement was natural under the circumstances:
we may compare the case of Xenophon, whose ‘Hellenica’
begin with the words Μετὰ
δὲ ταῦτα, οὐ
πολλαῖς
ἡμέραις
ὕστερον…, the
reference being to the end of the history of Thucydides. The view here
maintained is clinched by the fact that Athanasius at this very time
reissued his Apology against the Arians with an appendix
(§§89, 90) on the lapse of Hosius and Liberius For
another example of hastily inferred mutiliation, see §48, note
3..