An ecumenical council was a new experiment. Local
councils had long since grown to be a recognised organ of the Church
both for legislation and for judicial proceedings. But no precedent as
yet prescribed, no ecclesiastical law or theological principle had as
yet enthroned, the ‘General Council’ as the supreme
expression of the Church’s mind. Constantine had already referred
the case of the Donatists first to a select council at Rome under
bishop Miltiades, then to what Augustine (Ep. 43) has been
understood to call a ‘plenarium ecclesiæ universæ
concilium’ at Arles in 314. This remedy for schism was now to be
tried on a grander scale. That the heads of all the Churches of
Christendom should meet in free and brotherly deliberation, and should
testify to all the world their agreement in the Faith handed down
independently but harmoniously from the earliest times in Churches
widely remote in situation, and separated by differences of language,
race, and civilisation, is a grand and impressive idea, an idea
approximately realised at Nicæa as in no other assembly that has
ever met. The testimony of such an assembly carries the strongest
evidential weight; and the almost unanimous horror of the Nicene
Bishops at the novelty and profaneness of Arianism condemns it
irrevocably as alien to the immemorial belief of the Churches. But it
was one thing to perceive this, another to formulate the positive
belief of the Church in such a way as to exclude the heresy; one thing
to agree in condemning Arian formulæ, another to agree upon an
adequate test of orthodoxy. This was the problem which lay before the
council, and with which only its more clearsighted members tenaciously
grappled: this is the explanation of the reaction which followed, and
which for more than a generation, for well nigh half a century after,
placed its results in jeopardy. The number of bishops who met at
Nicæa was over 250 So Eus.
Vit. Const. iii. 8—over 270, Eustath. in Thdt. i.
8—in fact more than 300 (de Decr. 3), according to
Athanasius, who again, toward the end of his life (ad Afr. 2)
acquiesces in the precise figure 318 (Gen. xiv. 14; the Greek
numeral τιή
combines the Cross with the initial letters of the
Sacred Name) which a later generation adopted (it first occurs in the
alleged Coptic acts of the Council of Alexandria, 362, then in the
Letter of Liberius to the bishops of Asia in 365, infr.
§9), on grounds perhaps symbolical rather than
historical.. They represented many
nationalities (Euseb. ubi supra.), but only a handful came from
the West, the chief being Hosius, Cæcilian of Carthage, and the
presbyters sent by Silvester of Rome, whose age prevented his presence
in person. The council lasted from the end of May till Aug. 25 (see
D.C.A., 1389). With the many picturesque stories told of its incidents
we have nothing to do (Stanley’s Eastern Church, Socr. i.
10–12, Soz. i. 17, 18, Rufin. H. E. i. 3–5); but it
may be well to note the division of parties. (1) Of thoroughgoing
partisans of Arius, Secundus The name of
Secundus appears among the subscriptions (cf. Soz. i. 21) but this is
contradicted by the primary evidence (Letter of the Council in Soc. i.
9, Thdt. i. 9); cf. Philost. i. 9, 10. But there is evidence that there
were two Secundi. and Theonas alone scorned
all compromise. But Eusebius of Nicomedia, Theognis, Bishop of
Nicæa itself, and Maris of Chalcedon, also belonged to the inner
circle of Arians by conviction (Socr. i. 8; Soz. i. 21 makes up the
same number, but wrongly). The three last-named were pupils of Lucian
(Philost. ii. 15). Some twelve others (the chief names are Athanasius
of Anazarbus and Narcissus of Neronias, in Cilicia; Patrophilus of
Scythopolis, Aetius of Lydda, Paulinus of Tyre, Theodotus of Laodicea,
Gregory of Berytus, in Syria and Palestine; Menophantus of Ephesus; for
a fuller discussion see Gwatk. p. 31, n. 3) completed the strength of
the Arian party proper. (2) On the other hand a clearly formulated
doctrinal position in contrast to Arianism was taken up by a minority
only, although this minority carried the day. Alexander of Alexandria
of course was the rallying point of this wing, but the choice of the
formula proceeded from other minds. ‘γπόστασις and
οὑσία are one in the
Nicene formula: Alexander in 323 writes of τρεὶς
ὐποστάσεις.