Chapter 23.—Porphyry’s Account of the Responses Given by the Oracles of the gods
Concerning Christ.
For in his book called ἐκ λογίων φιλοσοφίας, in which he collects and comments upon
the responses which he pretends were uttered by the gods concerning divine things, he
says—I give his own words as they have been translated from the Greek: “To one who in-
quired what god he should propitiate in order to recall his wife from Christianity, Apollo
replied in the following verses.” Then the following words are given as those of Apollo:
“You will probably find it easier to write lasting characters on the water, or lightly fly like a
bird through the air, than to restore right feeling in your impious wife once she has polluted
herself. Let her remain as she pleases in her foolish deception, and sing false laments to her
dead God, who was condemned by right-minded judges, and perished ignominiously by a
violent death.” Then after these verses of Apollo (which we have given in a Latin version
that does not preserve the metrical form), he goes on to say: “In these verses Apollo exposed
the incurable corruption of the Christians, saying that the Jews, rather than the Christians,
416
recognized God.” See how he misrepresents Christ, giving the Jews the preference to the
Christians in the recognition of God. This was his explanation of Apollo’s verses, in which
he says that Christ was put to death by right-minded or just judges,—in other words, that
He deserved to die. I leave the responsibility of this oracle regarding Christ on the lying
interpreter of Apollo, or on this philosopher who believed it or possibly himself invented
it; as to its agreement with Porphyry’s opinions or with other oracles, we shall in a little have
something to say. In this passage, however, he says that the Jews, as the interpreters of God,
judged justly in pronouncing Christ to be worthy of the most shameful death. He should
have listened, then, to this God of the Jews to whom he bears this testimony, when that God
says, “He that sacrificeth to any other god save to the Lord alone shall be utterly destroyed.”
But let us come to still plainer expressions, and hear how great a God Porphyry thinks the
God of the Jews is. Apollo, he says, when asked whether word, i.e., reason, or law is the
better thing, replied in the following verses. Then he gives the verses of Apollo, from which
I select the following as sufficient: “God, the Generator, and the King prior to all things,
before whom heaven and earth, and the sea, and the hidden places of hell tremble, and the
deities themselves are afraid, for their law is the Father whom the holy Hebrews honor.”
In this oracle of his god Apollo, Porphyry avowed that the God of the Hebrews is so great
that the deities themselves are afraid before Him. I am surprised, therefore, that when God
said, He that sacrificeth to other gods shall be utterly destroyed, Porphyry himself was not
afraid lest he should be destroyed for sacrificing to other gods.
This philosopher, however, has also some good to say of Christ, oblivious, as it were,
of that contumely of his of which we have just been speaking; or as if his gods spoke evil of
Christ only while asleep, and recognized Him to be good, and gave Him His deserved praise,
when they awoke. For, as if he were about to proclaim some marvellous thing passing belief,
Porphyry’s Account of the Responses Given by the Oracles of the gods Concerning Christ.
938
Porphyry’s Account of the Responses Given by the Oracles of the gods Concerning…