Excursus on the Later History of Canon XXVIII.
Among the bishops who gave their answers at the last session to the question whether
their subscription to the canons was voluntary or forced was Eusebius, bishop of Dorylæum,
an Asiatic bishop who said that he had read the Constantinopolitan canon to “the holy pope
of Rome in presence of clerics of Constantinople, and that he had accepted it” (L. and C.,
Conc., iv. 815). But quite possibly this evidence is of little value. But what is more to the
point is that the Papal legates most probably had already at this very council recognized the
right of Constantinople to rank immediately after Rome. For at the very first session when
the Acts of the Latrocinium were read, it was found that to Flavian, the Archbishop of
Constantinople, was given only the fifth place. Against this the bishop protested and asked,
289
“Why did not Flavian receive his position?” and the papal legate Paschasinus answered:
“We will, please God, recognize the present bishop Anatolius of Constantinople as the first
[i.e. after us], but Dioscorus made Flavian the fifth.” It would seem to be in vain to attempt
to escape the force of these words by comparing with them the statement made in the last
session, in a moment of heat and indignation, by Lucentius the papal legate, that the canons
of Constantinople were not found among those of the Roman Code. It may well be that
this statement was true, and yet it does not in any way lessen the importance of the fact that
at the first session (a very different thing from the sixteenth) Paschasinus had admitted that
Constantinople enjoyed the second place. It would seem that Quesnel has proved his point,
notwithstanding the attempts of the Ballerini to counteract and overthrow his arguments.
It would be the height of absurdity for any one to attempt to deny that the canon of
Constantinople was entirely in force and practical execution, as far of those most interested
were concerned, long before the meeting of the council of Chalcedon, and in 394, only
thirteen years after the adoption of the canon, we find the bishop of Constantinople
presiding at a synod at which both the bishop of Alexandria and the bishop of Antioch were
present.
St. Leo made, in connexion with this matter, some statements which perhaps need not
be commented upon, but should certainly not be forgotten. In his epistle to Anatolius (no.
cvi.) in speaking of the third canon of Constantinople he says: “That document of certain
bishops has never been brought by your predecessors to the knowledge of the Apostolic
See.” And in writing to the Empress (Ep. cv., ad Pulch.) he makes the following statement,
strangely contrary to what she at least knew to be the fact, “To this concession a long course
of years has given no effect!”
We need not stop to consider the question why Leo rejected the xxviijth canon of
Chalcedon. It is certain that he rejected it and those who wish to see the motive of this re-
jection considered at length are referred to Quesnel and to the Ballerini; the former affirming
that it was because of its encroachments upon the prerogatives of his own see, the latter
urging that it was only out of his zeal for the keeping in full force of the Nicene decree.
Excursus on the Later History of Canon XXVIII.
537
Excursus on the Later History of Canon XXVIII.