1862-67] PROOFS OF RELIGION 237
will know now from whom it comes. If Mr. Graves has
time, I should like to know if he thinks it correct in point
of thought. That I have put what I had to say very feebly
and poorly, I keenly feel, and more now that I read it over
in the proofs than while writing it. But I hope that I
may have succeeded in what I cared most about, namely,
to be true in thought and fair towards my Author's argu-
ments ; and then, however poor the article may be in
other respects, it will at all events have been worth the
trouble of writing to me personally, as an explanation to
my Theist and Unitarian friends, who have the pre-
possession deeply rooted in their minds that if one is
orthodox one must be bigoted, and so vary between think-
ing one that, or supposing that expressions of interest and
sympathy imply agreement of opinion when they do not.
When I return home, which I expect to do in about
a fortnight, I mean to begin translating Bunsen's " God in
History."
CATHERINE to A FRIEND
1864.
You say, you suppose people with weak spines must be
content to remain always in a mist. The world would be
out of joint indeed if it were so, that those who most need
the great truths of religion to live by, should be the least
able to get at them. But you forget that the evidence for
them is of two kinds, as it is in every branch of knowledge
which is an art, as well as a science. The scientific proof
lies in their furnishing the best conceivable theory of the
universe that which explains the phenomena in the
simplest and most harmonious manner. I believe they do
this ; but to ascertain this, of course it is necessary to exa-
mine other theories, to see where they fit and where they
fail, and to compare them with the philosophy of Theism or
Christianity ; and people with weak spines certainly cannot
undertake the study involved here. But there is also the
same kind ofproof in religion that there is in every other kind
of art ; that is, you live or act by the rules of that art, and
the course of action thus guided answers ; from which you