increased the magnitude of the trial. For who in the world would lightly desert a man of so
great genius, so great learning, so great influence, and would not rather adopt that saying,
That he would rather be wrong with Origen, than be right with others.82
What shall I say more? The result was that very many were led astray from the integrity
of the faith, not by any human excellencies of this so great man, this so great doctor, this so
great prophet, but, as the event showed, by the too perilous trial which he proved to be.
Hence it came to pass, that this Origen, such and so great as he was, wantonly abusing the
grace of God, rashly following the bent of his own genius, and placing overmuch confidence
in himself, making light account of the ancient simplicity of the Christian religion, presuming
145
that he knew more than all the world besides, despising the traditions of the Church and
the determinations of the ancients, and interpreting certain passages of Scripture in a novel
way, deserved for himself the warning given to the Church of God, as applicable in his case
as in that of others, “If there arise a prophet in the midst of thee,”… “thou shalt not hearken
to the words of that prophet,”…“because the Lord your God doth make trial of you,
whether you love Him or not.”83 Truly, thus of a sudden to seduce the Church which was
devoted to him, and hung upon him through admiration of his genius, his learning, his
eloquence, his manner of life and influence, while she had no fear, no suspicion for her-
self,—thus, I say, to seduce the Church, slowly and little by little, from the old religion to a
new profaneness, was not only a trial, but a great trial.84
[45.] But some one will say, Origen’s books have been corrupted. I do not deny it; nay,
I grant it readily. For that such is the case has been handed down both orally and in writing,
not only by Catholics, but by heretics as well. But the point is, that though himself be not,
yet books published under his name are, a great trial, which, abounding in many hurtful
blasphemies, are both read and delighted in, not as being some one else’s, but as being be-
lieved to be his, so that, although there was no error in Origen’s original meaning, yet Origen’s
authority appears to be an effectual cause in leading people to embrace error.
82 Errare malo cum Platone quam cum istis vera sentire.—Cicero, Tuscul. Quæst. 1.
83 Deuteronomy xiii. 1.
84 “The great Origen died after his many labors in peace. His immediate pupils were saints and rulers in the
Church. He has the praise of St. Athanasius, St. Basil, and St. Gregory Nazianzen, and furnishes materials to St.
Ambrose and St. Hilary; yet, as time proceeded a definite heterodoxy was the growing result of his theology,
and at length, three hundred years after his death, he was condemned, and, as has generally been considered,
in an Œcumenical Council.”—Newman on Development, p. 85, First Edition.
334
Chapter XVII. The Error of Origen a great Trial to the Church.