§35. Proof that the Anomœan teaching tends to Manichæism.
We hear our Lord saying. “I and My Father are one,” and we are taught in that utterance
the dependence of our Lord on a cause, and yet the absolute identity of the Son’s and the
Father’s nature; we do not let our idea about them be melted down into One Person, but
we keep distinct the properties of the Persons, while, on the other hand, not dividing in the
Persons the oneness of their substance; and so the supposition of two diverse principles in
the category of Cause is avoided, and there is no loophole for the Manichæan heresy to
enter. For the created and the uncreate are as diametrically opposed to each other as their
names are; and so if the two are to be ranked as First Causes, the mischief of Manichæism
will thus under cover be brought into the Church. I say this, because my zeal against our
antagonists makes me scrutinize their doctrine very closely. Now I think that none would
deny that we were bringing this scrutiny very near the truth, when we said, that if the created
82
be possessed of equal power with the uncreate, there will be some sort of antagonism between
these things of diverse nature, and as long as neither of them fails in power, the two will be
brought into a certain state of mutual discord for we must perforce allow that will corresponds
with, and is intimately joined to nature; and that if two things are unlike in nature, they will
be so also in will. But when power is adequate in both, neither will flag in the gratification
of its wish; and if the power of each is thus equal to its wish, the primacy will become a
doubtful point with the two: and it will end in a drawn battle from the inexhaustibleness of
their powers. Thus will the Manichæan heresy creep in, two opposite principles appearing
with counter claims in the category of Cause, parted and opposed by reason of difference
both in nature and in will. They will find, therefore, that assertion of diminution (in the
Divine being) is the beginning of Manichæism; for their teaching organizes a discord within
that being, which comes to two leading principles, as our account of it has shewn; namely
the created and the uncreated.
But perhaps most will blame this as too strong a reductio ad absurdum, and will wish
that we had not put it down at all along with our other objections. Be it so; we will not con-
tradict them. It was not our impulse, but our adversaries themselves, that forced us to carry
our argument into such minuteness of results. But if it is not right to argue thus, it was more
fitting still that our opponents’ teaching, which gave occasion to such a refutation, should
never have been heard. There is only one way of suppressing the answer to bad teaching,
and that is, to take away the subject-matter to which a reply has to be made. But what would
give me most pleasure would be to advise those, who are thus disposed, to divest themselves
a little of the spirit of rivalry, and not be such exceedingly zealous combatants on behalf of
the private opinions with which they have become possessed, and convinced that the race
is for their (spiritual) life, to attend to its interests only, and to yield the victory to Truth. If,
then, one were to cease from this ambitious strife, and look straight into the actual question
before us, he would very soon discover the flagrant absurdity of this teaching.
Proof that the Anomœan teaching tends to Manichæism.
156
Proof that the Anomœan teaching tends to Manichæism.